So, after careful study, consideration, time, love, and tenderness, I spent the summer listening to In the Nightside Eclipse and Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk, a whole lot. Even more than usual I should say, and I've had them for 8ish years now I guess. Conclusions:
They are both pinnacles of not only black metal, but also heavy metal, and truly, music in general. I finally "get" why these are both heralded as true classics. I always liked Anthems, but definitely took issue with Nightside for several years, for whatever reason. I wouldn't consider either album easy to get into, and I'm glad that I stayed strong for the course!
Anyhow, I have a very slight preference for Anthems. Very slight. I like the flow better, as it is more consistent. That being said, Nightside starts off good but only gets better and better as it progresses, and that is quite a remarkable thing to accomplish. The closing minute or so is pure fucking glory.
ITT: I conjure conclusions that others realized by 1999. Also I like reading my old opinions that I now completely disagree with. Ron Paul? Really?