I voted A Fair Judgement. I love the melody, the solos, and the "Leave it be" section, everything about it, the guitar, the solos, the drums, the vocals, the bass, it's all perfect. The little classical interlude is wonderful, idiosyncratic and beautiful, and then that awesome riff before the final solos.
I love this album though, great songs all around. And really, depending on the day any song (except FAF, which is great, but how can it compare) could have taken it.
For some reason I never want to listen to Master's Apprentices but when it comes on I always think, "Jesus this is an awesome song", and then Jesus says, "Umm, the name's Mikael actually"