Game: ultimate metal band 2007

[Kenneth R.]

uh, you should update the numbers on the left to reflect your changes!

 

[Siren]

16 - Samael (+1)
08 - Paradise Lost
13 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
13 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
19 - At the Gates (+1)
15 - Dissection
16 - Agalloch (-1)
11 - Disillusion
15 - The Kovenant
11 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root (-1)
15 - Neurosis
08 - Marduk
11 - Naglfar

I have a small problem giving my negative votes, since my familiarity with most of the bands is not enough to reject them. And i'm not in a 'checking out bands' mood either. I know it's not very fair, but well..

 

[QRV]

16 - Samael
07 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing (-1)
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
19 - At the Gates
15 - Dissection
15 - Agalloch (-1)
12 - Disillusion
15 - The Kovenant
14 - Swallow the Sun
09 - Root (+1)
15 - Neurosis
09 - Marduk (+1)
10 - Naglfar

edit: ishkur's post was rather messed up. I've already fixed it up.

 

[QRV]

I'm confused as to what exactly is "forum time".

No worries, just vote according to your own time. UM time is just a help in case no band is eliminated within 3 days, or if somebody tries to cheat.



Btw, maybe it should have been better if Blind Guardian was there instead of Kamelot as a representative of power metal. I do think Kamelot is one of the most decent PM bands out there, but it didn't stand a chance here.

 

[Wolfman Von Jones]

17 - Samael (+1)
07 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
20 - At the Gates (+1)
15 - Dissection
15 - Agalloch
12 - Disillusion
15 - The Kovenant
14 - Swallow the Sun
09 - Root
15 - Neurosis
07 - Marduk (-2)
10 - Naglfar

 

[brownden]

16 - Samael (-1)
07 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
20 - At the Gates
14 - Dissection (-1)
15 - Agalloch
12 - Disillusion
15 - The Kovenant
16 - Swallow the Sun (+2)
09 - Root
15 - Neurosis
07 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar

 

[afz902k]

Why do people hate marduk T__T ?

 

[Siren]

Btw, maybe it should have been better if Blind Guardian was there instead of Kamelot as a representative of power metal. I do think Kamelot is one of the most decent PM bands out there, but it didn't stand a chance here.

Blind Guardian would have probably lasted longer, indeed. I didn't suggest Kamelot as a PM band though, i very much dislike power metal. But their latest album is awesome, and i'm not even sure if it's still classified under the PM brand.

 

[King Chaos]

16 - Samael
07 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
20 - At the Gates (-1)
14 - Dissection
15 - Agalloch
13 - Disillusion (+1)
14 - The Kovenant (-1)
16 - Swallow the Sun
09 - Root
16 - Neurosis (+1)
07 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar

 

[QRV]

Why do people hate marduk T__T ?

I ask myself the same question. Marduk at their worst is still far better than 50,000 black metal bands out there.

 

[Salamurhaaja]

I can see nothing even worth bothering for on that list, except maybe
The Kovenant, but the rest can burn for all I care.

How the hell were the band selected anyway, did they do something this year?

 

[Kovenant84]

16 - Samael
07 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
19 - At the Gates (-1)
14 - Dissection
15 - Agalloch
13 - Disillusion
16 - The Kovenant (+2)
16 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root (-1)
16 - Neurosis
07 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar

~kov. (slightly early, but no matter)

 

[Kenneth R.]

16 - Samael
07 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
19 - At the Gates
14 - Dissection
17 - Agalloch +2
13 - Disillusion
16 - The Kovenant
16 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root
16 - Neurosis
05 - Marduk -2
10 - Naglfar

 

[QRV]

Either you guys are eliminating the bands you don't know, or you have really awful tastes.

 

[Dark_Silence]

16 - Samael
06 - Paradise Lost
13 - Thyrfing(+2)
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
12 - Decapitated
18 - At the Gates (-2)
14 - Dissection
17 - Agalloch
13 - Disillusion
16 - The Kovenant
16 - Swallow the Sun
07 - Root
16 - Neurosis
05 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar

 

[King Chaos]

16 - Samael
06 - Paradise Lost
13 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
12 - Decapitated
17 - At the Gates (-1)
14 - Dissection
17 - Agalloch
15 - Disillusion (+2)
16 - The Kovenant
16 - Swallow the Sun
07 - Root
16 - Neurosis
05 - Marduk
09 - Naglfar (-1)

 

[QRV]

16 - Samael
06 - Paradise Lost
13 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
12 - Decapitated
17 - At the Gates
14 - Dissection
17 - Agalloch
15 - Disillusion
14 - The Kovenant (-2)
16 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root (+1)
16 - Neurosis
06 - Marduk (+1)
09 - Naglfar

 

[Sunshine]

15 - Samael (-1)
08 - Paradise Lost (+2)
13 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
12 - Decapitated
17 - At the Gates
14 - Dissection
17 - Agalloch
15 - Disillusion
14 - The Kovenant
15 - Swallow the Sun (-1)
08 - Root
16 - Neurosis
06 - Marduk
09 - Naglfar

 

[Siren]

16 - Samael (+1)
08 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing (-2)
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
12 - Decapitated
18 - At the Gates (+1)
14 - Dissection
17 - Agalloch
15 - Disillusion
14 - The Kovenant
15 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root
16 - Neurosis
06 - Marduk
09 - Naglfar

 

[brownden]

16 - Samael
08 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
13 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
12 - Decapitated
18 - At the Gates
14 - Dissection
17 - Agalloch
15 - Disillusion
14 - The Kovenant
17 - Swallow the Sun (+2)
08 - Root
16 - Neurosis
04 - Marduk (-2)
09 - Naglfar