Good metal or trying to hard?

Hahaha, cool. It is my band. I play guitar. I figured the only way to get an opinion out of people was to not let them know.

The drums were triggered so they sound almost computer like. The vocals are all fucked up and improvised. We have a lazy vocalist so no lyrics or nothing. I like our music though.
 
New1 started off decent, but basically, I couldn't focus on anything. It was all kinda boring. Not bad boring...just...*yawn*. Kinda like a black metal dream theater...good musicianship, but going nowhere aimlessly. If I wanted atmosphere, I'd put on something without blastbeats...if I want aggression, I would definitely not want to listen to this.

Kudos to you though - way better than anything I could ever do! (I don't play) :)

Scott
 
No punches held. I'm glad to get an honest opinion about the music. Musician or not I like to hear what people really think.

New1 needs a guitar solo or something in it. Our original formula was 2 solos in every song. That ended after the first 2 songs, ha.