Squash Player said:I Would Like To Use This Forum To Scream A Great Fuck To Those Bastards Who Killed Our Men In Iraq.
Hail!
i personally rate people as more important than cats on a broad scale - even though there might be exceptions: for instance i'd much rather see some cats alive than their owners - and i think this episode differs from other acts of war on two levels: magnitude (it's the wider war onslaught of people from our nation after ww2) and method (it's a terrorist attack in an assumingly pacified area, not a "regular" fight in a certified war zone).Miolo said:this thread is disgustingly populist. people die in wars every day. if a man goes to war he has a high chance of being killed. what should we do then? open a new thread for every time an american/italian/whatever soldier dies? of course i'm saddened by the death of those men, as i'm saddened by the death of idari's cat.
i'm afraid i happen to have limited control over the solar system. if i had i'm sure you would have noticed by now, just by glancing briefly at uranus.a_hole said:I'm cool about that, I was just expressing myself. Feel free to feedback whenever
rahvin said:i'm afraid i happen to have limited control over the solar system. if i had i'm sure you would have noticed by now, just by glancing briefly at uranus.
the whole war has never had the characteristics of a "regular" one. such an attack is at least predictable since american soldiers has been dying regularly from acts of guerrilla since the "end" of the war.rahvin said:i personally rate people as more important than cats on a broad scale - even though there might be exceptions: for instance i'd much rather see some cats alive than their owners - and i think this episode differs from other acts of war on two levels: magnitude (it's the wider war onslaught of people from our nation after ww2) and method (it's a terrorist attack in an assumingly pacified area, not a "regular" fight in a certified war zone).
when i mentioned "populism" i had clearly in mind the pathetic attitude that the italian media put on yesterday, and since i know squash player personally, i'm sure the attitude was the same.rahvin said:however, i wouldn't focus critics on the opening of threads or not: if i feel like mourning for the loss of human lives who were spent in a way i deem valueable, i don't think i could be called a populist: not everything the masses do is wrong just because the masses do it. according to this principle, restraining from rape and murder is populism as it exactly embodies the following of a very wide-spread trend.
in fact, this shouldn't have been a "war" at all, in the areas where our soldiers are deployed and according to the reasons of our parliament for sending our soldiers over. as a consequence, unlike the american camps, ours was poorly guarded and actually treated as if there was no battlefield around it, just houses and civilians. the level of danger was obviously underrated. this is exactly one of the reasons why i call this event out of the ordinary and i feel so much for those who died, victims of poor military strategy and unfirm political control over the operations in iraq. the fact that the attack was predictable does nothing to make me feel better about the deceased: it's not as if you can say "they've been looking for it!", if incompetent people make mistakes and soldiers and civilians get involved, it doesn't make me want to dismiss the thing as "just another episode".Miolo said:the whole war has never had the characteristics of a "regular" one. such an attack is at least predictable since american soldiers has been dying regularly from acts of guerrilla since the "end" of the war.
however, said pathetic attitude didn't stop the italian media to broadcast advertisements during the one minute of silence before the beginning of a totally irrelevant football match that hasn't been called off. so what can we say about the way the supposed "people" in "populism" feel about the events? that they do not really give a fucking shit, let alone starting threads on boards online.when i mentioned "populism" i had clearly in mind the pathetic attitude that the italian media put on yesterday, and since i know squash player personally, i'm sure the attitude was the same.
there isn't. it seemed like you wre criticising the very idea of opening threads for mourning the loss of human lives as inherently hipocritical and i objected to that. what we choose to feel or do is undoubtedly another kettle of fish.there isn't anything wrong in feeling like mourning for the loss of those human lives, but i'm not feeling mourning for that and there shouldn't be anything wrong in this as well.
i'm not saying they've been looking for it, but as i stated before, if you're sent to war (even if it wasn't supposed to be an actual war, only a fool could consider nassirya, or any other iraqi town, a 'safe' place) being killed is a realistic consequence. i agree that incompetent people made mistakes, but this only increases my anger towards those who sent the soldiers.rahvin said:in fact, this shouldn't have been a "war" at all, in the areas where our soldiers are deployed and according to the reasons of our parliament for sending our soldiers over. as a consequence, unlike the american camps, ours was poorly guarded and actually treated as if there was no battlefield around it, just houses and civilians. the level of danger was obviously underrated. this is exactly one of the reasons why i call this event out of the ordinary and i feel so much for those who died, victims of poor military strategy and unfirm political control over the operations in iraq. the fact that the attack was predictable does nothing to make me feel better about the deceased: it's not as if you can say "they've been looking for it!", if incompetent people make mistakes and soldiers and civilians get involved, it doesn't make me want to dismiss the thing as "just another episode".
i didn't know of the adverts during the one minute of silence. well, that shows how hypocritical they are, and is exactly why i was criticising them. the fact that squash player opened this thread just because of the nationality of the deceased is something i couldn't tolerate.rahvin said:however, said pathetic attitude didn't stop the italian media to broadcast advertisements during the one minute of silence before the beginning of a totally irrelevant football match that hasn't been called off. so what can we say about the way the supposed "people" in "populism" feel about the events? that they do not really give a fucking shit, let alone starting threads on boards online.
clearly i cannot comment about squash player's reasons aside from what's written here, so i concede you may have a point there.".
i was just criticising the very idea of mourning the loss of human lives just because they were of our same country. i'm sorry if i've been misunderstood.rahvin said:there isn't. it seemed like you wre criticising the very idea of opening threads for mourning the loss of human lives as inherently hipocritical and i objected to that. what we choose to feel or do is undoubtedly another kettle of fish.