I agree with you (mtlheart) to an extent; I couldn't help but cringe at people berating this MallcoreDude, when they don't know his exact situation. That's why my reply to him wasn't inflammatory; I was just giving him advice.
However, the point you're still missing, which Met-Al understands now, is that Aki is our friend. Not "friend" in the sense of "brothers of metal from around the world" or any such nonsense as that. Those of us who chose to help Aki actually KNOW him, have hung out with him in person on multiple occasions, and, in some cases, have been friends with him for five years or longer.
the other thread was some random person asking for money for himself.
What curufin said. However, this is the
least important reason why the two situations are different. Think about it. If you're short on next month's rent, who are you going to ask for help: your friends/family, or complete strangers? This MallcoreGuy asked a bunch of people who don't know him for financial assistance in traveling to a concert, whereas curufin's donation page for Aki stated, specifically, that it was for friends of Aki. The reason it was here on the ProgPower board was obviously because it seems to be the most centralized place for Aki's friends to see it.
Speaking of scams, the thread started by Mallcore Massacre is a prime example of what I was worried about. I thought that this thread would prompt some selfish bastard to try raising money for his or herself.
I don't think any of us know for a fact that MallcoreGuy's intention was to scam money out of us; perhaps he's legit as well, or perhaps he's someone from this board who is just trying to "make a point" under a separate screen name. However, we're adults here, and we each have the ability and the right to differentiate for ourselves who truly needs our financial help and who doesn't. Let the scammers come; they'll be ignored, ridiculed, or deleted. Who cares?