- Feb 29, 2008
- 7,449
- 938
- 113
i really don't think it's pedantry. cd (and minidisc, and DAT, and a million other digital formats that aren't just a file on a computer) isn't a "technically" digital format or digital only in some sort of academic sense, it is very much straight up digital audio and have been referred to as such for decades.Pedantry aside, it provides a way of distinguishing between physical and non-physical though, so I don't see what the harm is.
now referring to a digital download as a digital download, that's fine (although redundant, because no one is really "downloading" analog data), but not solely "digital" because it makes no sense and does not convey what you're trying to convey. "digital" is a way of storing data, not a method of distributing it.
if you're trying to distinguish between physical and non-physical, you can say "physical" and "non-physical" imo