neal
wizard in black
i kinda skimmed the thread so i dunno if these points have been brough up....
the A bombs were dropped for a number of reasons, first and most important was to stop the war. the US was considdering an invasion of japan with a projected possible loss of 1 million soldiers, so dropping some bombs was a more attractive option. the A bombs killed less people than the regular fire-bombings of tokyo had anyway, and those bombings would have continued so they actually saved a lot of japanese lives as well. claiming it was military tagets was BS though, they dropped the bombs over the most populated areas i.e. residential. the reason for the second was to show japan AND the rest of the world (especially russia who we knew would be our biggest rival for world supremecy) that we had as many of these motherfuckers as we needed to take out our enemies (even though we only had those 2 at the time). japan didnt really have a chance to surrender in between the two even though they probably wouldnt have anyway...so id say dropping the bombs was the best solution. way better than a fuckin invasion.
-neal
the A bombs were dropped for a number of reasons, first and most important was to stop the war. the US was considdering an invasion of japan with a projected possible loss of 1 million soldiers, so dropping some bombs was a more attractive option. the A bombs killed less people than the regular fire-bombings of tokyo had anyway, and those bombings would have continued so they actually saved a lot of japanese lives as well. claiming it was military tagets was BS though, they dropped the bombs over the most populated areas i.e. residential. the reason for the second was to show japan AND the rest of the world (especially russia who we knew would be our biggest rival for world supremecy) that we had as many of these motherfuckers as we needed to take out our enemies (even though we only had those 2 at the time). japan didnt really have a chance to surrender in between the two even though they probably wouldnt have anyway...so id say dropping the bombs was the best solution. way better than a fuckin invasion.
-neal