Melodyne vs Auto Tune 7

[Nick M]

I use melodyne studio for natural sounding pitch correction. Autotune gets the effect type stuff done(core singers and T payne). Melodyne is very powerful but you really need to correct the detection especially if it is an aggressive singer. Once the detection is in place, its great. I never had a glitchy part I could not fix and make perfect with melodyne, just some working of the detection and processing.

But, you should have both.

 

[Machinated]

I use melodyne studio for natural sounding pitch correction. Autotune gets the effect type stuff done(core singers and T payne).

this is a bit of a misconception. use autotune in graphic mode, not auto mode. similar kind of dealio to melodyne.

i actually think it sounds more natural personally.

 

[Nick M]

It can get very natural correction in graphical mode as long as the singer is close. Most of the time there are notes that are a little out of autotunes reach for natural sounds. I find melodyne can do more extreme processing without getting as effect ish.

 

[OneDaySky]

It can get very natural correction in graphical mode as long as the singer is close. Most of the time there are notes that are a little out of autotunes reach for natural sounds. I find melodyne can do more extreme processing without getting as effect ish.

I agree with the whole melodyne working better on extreme cases, like being off by 3 semitones or more. But the bottom line is to get it super close at the recording stage and then use autotune to fix it (in graphical)

 

[Erratic]

Tune By Waves

/thread