Most Talented Anthraxian

MetalThrasher442 · Oct 13, 2005

Who do you think the most talented band member of Anthrax is(was) and why?

My pick is Charlie. My favorite drummer. And me being a drummer myself i've learned a couple things on the drums from him.

JohnThrax · Oct 13, 2005

MetalThrasher442 · Oct 13, 2005

JohnThrax said:
Cags

Really? He was awesome but Danny is better.

JohnThrax · Oct 13, 2005

MetalThrasher442 said:
Really? He was awesome but Danny is better.

gotta disagree. Rob is easily the better shredder

spitzs lazy eye · Oct 14, 2005

Dan, he's the watchmaker, do the math!!!

seriously, Charlie, plays more than just the drums and has been since a young age. Talented man. Having to be snuck into pubs and clubs when he was way under age to play some gigs is saying something.

strik9 · Oct 14, 2005

Imo it's a tossup between Scott and Charlie. 'Cause I'm a guitar player I'm going with Scott!

He's an amazing guitarist, a talented lyricist, and he's just written some awesome shit over the years! Plus he came up with Sgt. D!

For My Sweetheart the Drunk · Oct 14, 2005

Ian and Charlie are the most talented in Anthrax bar none...

DeathsHead · Oct 14, 2005

Ian and Charlie are the most talented in Anthrax bar none

No, Ian and Charlie are Anthrax

For My Sweetheart the Drunk · Oct 14, 2005

DeathsHead said:
No, Ian and Charlie are Anthrax

I was going to say that, but then I thought it was too cliché....

lovehunter · Oct 14, 2005

Charlie.:Smokin:

crimsoid · Oct 14, 2005

Charlie...maybe one of the best drummers ever....He's up there with Peart and well Bill Bruford...other than that....Lars is good but not great...now Dave Lombardo is awesome but I think Charlie is better.

Parviainen · Oct 14, 2005

Scott and Charlie.

CAI · Oct 14, 2005

Charlie all the waaayyyyy!!! Anthrax without him would had been an average band.

DumbAss · Oct 14, 2005

Charlie... no Contest. But Rob is a smokin' Guitar Player.

Whiplash402 · Oct 15, 2005

easily charlie i dont get y people r saying scott i mean the guy is amazing but charlie is like a legend

Descendent · Oct 15, 2005

Nobody has mentioned that Charlie is a phenominal guitar player, as well as a fantastic drummer.

johnnieCzech · Oct 15, 2005

John Bush

spacebeer · Oct 15, 2005

I think it's all about Joey and Charlie, but Scott also has a very unique approach to riffing which cannot be copied easily, though he lost that touch on the recent albums which sounded far more generic....

spacebeer · Oct 15, 2005

JohnThrax said:
gotta disagree. Rob is easily the better shredder

Totally disagreed! gimme Dan] his leads flow far better with the songs he really knows what he's doing...I wouldn't call either of them shredders though....