MUSICAL PIRACY:Just one question.

As far as i'm aware its not the burning part of piracy that's illegal - its the sharing/downloading part of it. Otherwise I would could legally download music as long as I didn't burn it. CD manufacturers have nothing to do with it.
 
This argument is obviously ridiculous as many people have pointed out already. Another comparison would be HD manufacturers (HDs are frequently used as storage devices for pirated material) and what about internet providers? I bet the majority of the people here frequently use their internet connection to download or upload copyrighted material.
 
Although I agree with the argument that most people use cd burners for other things besides pirating music. However there is no doubt that they are being used for pirating music and very frequently. The problem is that their is no way to prove that cd burners are designed and used specifically for stealing music, the manufacturers claim its an individual problem and use the legal applications as justification for their use.

It's a slippery subject and cannot be compared to drunk drivers killing people, pirating music is a widespread phenomenon with very little negative aspects for the users engaging in it. The vague threat of the labels catching and suing a specific user compared with the threat killing yourself and other innocent people with a car is simply not in context. However I do agree that it is a very tough subject and one without a specific accountability but I think as long as the manufacturers are able to hold up the legal aspects of cd burners I am sure there will never be a courtroom confrontation with them and record labels.