I have a friend that swears when I do final production on cd's at the studio I do them much louder than commercial releases but everything is still in order. I like it. I would rather have to turn the volume down a little to match my normal listening range than be pissed because my knob is all the way up and it's still not loud enough. Maybe if this guy or his friend at Tiny PhoneBooth or whatever it's called knew how to level out a project before mixing it, they could make theirs loud too. Like it should be. Everything is done much louder these days. If you listen to something before digital recording came around, and compare it to something from current times...it will be much louder. A lot of old recordings are being re-mastered for this reason. And because it's muffled, or the low end just isn't there like it use to be. I'm sure back in the day when bands like Whitesnake and such came around they were "too loud", but even their recordings don't compare to the rock/metal albums of today. The industry is just getting louder as time goes by.
Death Cab for Cutie was one of those new "up and coming" bands that were suppose to hit big a while back in whatever genre they are in. Dunno much else about them.
As far as I'm concerned, digital has revolutionized the recording industry. It's much easier now than ever to throw tracks down. Punch-in a million times and everything still sounds the same as the first time through. You don't have to tell a band "alright, you gotta get it down perfect this time or else we have to start over again", lol. Tape is not cheap anymore, and there's a reason. It is a personal preference, but if you notice, probably 99% of your favorite albums nowadays WERE done all digital. Most of the big name studios have switched over to digital a long time ago. I just think people should keep with the times and get over it. Digital is here to stay, trust me it's not going anywhere. Besides, there are plug-ins and other things you can use to recreate that tape sound if absolutely must have it. It's just hiss, less high-end, and a certain mid-range....generally speaking of course. I dunno, maybe if I had some more experience with tape I would be more loving of it, but the experiences I have had were tedious, and horrible. I'm so glad it was only so I could learn how to use the machine, lol. Yep.
~006