I never really perceived STD to be scooped sounding though.
Just A/B both the Panic Broadcast and STD back to back, STD in fact sounds a bit middier, which seem to be mostly due to that odd mid spike that I remember Ermz talking about when he made that STD love (see what I did there
) thread. I tend to think if the guitars have much more mids than that, it starts to cloud over the mix a bit.
Something about the way Bogren mixes the snare drum seems to really let down his mixes. It's like, his mixes are really cool, but the snares are always too dark sounding and too small, and just don't cut through enough.
Definitely noticed it on the Katatonia records he has engineered and mix, as well as the Opeth stuff he's done.