While the promo version's music was well received, many journalists and music critics were upset or angry that the band released a "fake" version of The Ape of God albums. Guitarist Nate Newton said that some journalists felt that Old Man Gloom had "besmirched their profession" and also said that: "People either love [the joke] or they're fucking angry. It was just an idea that came up and we thought, 'Yeah that's funny. Let's do that.' I had no idea people would be so angry." Adrien Begrand of the American heavy metal magazine Decibel was one such journalist, and in a round-up of new album releases for November 2014 said: "I'd been thoroughly digging what I was hearing, but when the band revealed that the promo was merely a fake in order to hoodwink writers and weed out leakers, I didn't appreciate being jerked around and having my precious time wasted by a bunch of smug musicians who think they're being funny. Besides, Profound Lore uses [the online music promo software] Haulix, nearly all metal labels use Haulix, and with that promo platform a band or label can easily track down the person responsible for an album leak. The 'fake promo' idea might have been clever a decade ago, but not in 2014."