When, mostly because of the "And I Cried..." stanza. Pure uninspired cliche songwriting and rhyming. My least favorite Opeth moment ever. Fortunately everything after that is brilliant, but not enough to make it better than the other two.
When and April Ethereal are the best songs on Mayh and prolly my favorite 2 consecutive Opeth songs. There is just no way Demon of the Fall is better than When. Seriously. I can go on and on like most of you why they are better but the outro to April Ethereal and at 5:05 on When is just the greatest thing ever written. That song is what makes me the Opeth groupie I am today! And I don't care wtf people say! Wait! Vote Demon! Just not When...