Well, you do have a point. I suppose I shouldn't have said Barker was talentless. It takes talent to learn a skill(playing the drums). I don't understand where the talent is in blastbeating though. Nearly every Death Metal and Black Metal band I hear incorpates ridiculous drumming into every song, usually the entire length of it. I don't play an instrument, but I don't see the talent in pounding away at the drums like a child who is just having his/her first orgasm. I haven't really heard much else from Barker but his absurd drumming tendencies. No amount of riffs or melodies could make a song sound even remotely good with a bunch of smashing in the background. Opeth just wouldn't be Opeth. They would be leveled off to a mediocre band with a trendwhore passion of trying to be as agressive as possible. I seriously think there is a race out there---"How many hits per second can you accomplish?"
Well, that's my ignorant take and my 2 cents.