I really hope you weren't offended and I mean that in all sincerity. It doesn't seem like you were offended so I'm happy about that...
Nope, and I'm glad you picked up on that.
To answer your question, that would depend on the manner in which one reacts to reading something that bothers him/her. Would I spew soda all over my keyboard and then light my monitor on fire and punch a hole in the wall then make personal threats to the person? Of course not...to me, THAT is the definition of taking the intarweb too seriously.
However, responding in kind to something posted on a forum, even with sharp words occasionally (hopefully not insulting or berating), would absolutely be appropriate. That's what it's there for; we can't all be made out of sunshine and popcorn farts.
Well, how someone reacts is kind of what we're talking about here. I still believe people can overreact with just their words, too.
I get this feeling from you (and please correct me if I'm wrong) that you feel by not blowing off or ignoring an argument, you automatically are vulnerable to ridicule. It seems like maybe you feel that responding to someone seriously on a message board makes you look stupid, almost like your friends are watching you type and you want to save face.
It's actually harder for me to put together a response to an argument these days because over the years I've realized it's just not worth the effort in the end. I definitely don't feel stupid responding to anyone here, and in lieu of sounding completely arrogant, the truth is actually the opposite of what you're implying. I probably have a bit of a superiority complex, which also plays into my decisions NOT to post sometimes ("not even gonna bother, no one would get it anyways..." for example.). I respond sarcastically to the things I think aren't worth my serious attention. When I think something deems a serious reply (like this conversation), I have absolutely zero qualms about doing it. It's honestly a little bit hard for me to believe that you haven't figured this out yet and come to understand when I'm joking and when I'm being serious. It doesn't seem to be a problem with most people.
You see, when I read that big long response you posted, your point of view was made much more clear than posting something short and sarcastic. The people here who try to be funny with sarcasm really aren't; they're just being assholes. By now you know I'm very opinionated and have points of view that many would consider me an asshole, and that's perfectly fine because that's who I am. But I'm not trying to hide behind passive aggressive sarcasm like so many others. If yer gonna be an asshole, just be up front about it. (This isn't about you, just in general)
It was clear to you because I intentionally made it clear. If I didn't give a shit about the conversation I either wouldn't have replied or I would have said something ridiculous because I know it gets your goat and it makes me laugh when you fly off the handle and go on a word frenzy defending yourself. It's nothing personal at all. In my eyes, it's fun and harmless. If it really does bother you, then I don't know what else to tell you besides "sorry, but I'm not going to stop." I know you're very opionated and that's totally fine. The thing is though, nobody fucking cares about anyone else's opinion unless they ask for it. That goes for you, me, everyone else on this board and everyone else in the entire universe. I remember this every single time I make an opinionated post. I understand that some or a lot of people might dislike my opinion enough to talk shit about it or make fun of it and that's fine. I'm not going to be surprised about it and feel the need to incessantly defend myself against a bunch of people who, in all honesty, probably don't really care about me in the first place. If I were going to be an asshole, I WOULD be up front about it and I would expect people to fuck with me. But I wouldn't get upset or pissed because of it, because I'd know I was an asshole, and assholes deserve that kind of shit.
I do think you should just be honest with yourself and stop worrying about what other people think about you, even though you may tell yourself you don't care. There's nothing wrong with failing to live up to every single one of your expectations you've set for yourself; we're only human.
Well I guess I can't really reply to this since you pre-emptively stole the true answer from me. So instead of telling myself I don't care what people think of me, I will tell you. I don't care what people think of me. You can believe that or not, I have no control over that. But I know how I feel right now as I think and type about this and that's that I truly mean what I say and I'm not denying anything to myself. I admit that I enjoy positive attention (who doesn't?) but I do not crave it or require it. I admit that I dislike negative attention, but I am willing to deal with it.
Sure, maybe you, neal, and Captain Beard will continue to gang up on me and ridicule me for responding seriously to a topic, but that's fine. It's fun sometimes. If they died today, I really wouldn't care...and that's the asshole part of me. That's truly not caring about anyone...their opinions, their lives, etc., not saying "I don't give a shit" and then bottling it all up inside. But I'm honest about it and I don't need to hide behind sarcasm or pretend I don't care to prove my point.
Here's a big part of the problem. Your perception of the way you are treated. I've already said in this post that nothing is personal. I can't speak for anyone else, but it's not like I'm seething with rage when I call you out or make a joke or something. I do it because the opportunity presents itself. You always make such a big deal out of everything when you get picked on and I think that perpetuates others to poke more. If you could take things with a grain of salt a little more frequently I think you might find yourself putting together less wordfests to defend yourself.
Also, you mentioned me specifically at the begining of this paragraph, so I'll assume you're referring to me when you say I pretend to not care and bottle things up. That is simply not true and I think it's kind of a stupid assumption to make and ultimately something I might decide to make fun of if we weren't already in the middle of real talk time. Things aren't bottled up, they're merely remembered. It's not like I carry around a bunch of internet forum baggage with me everywhere I go that constantly eats me from the inside out.
I personally prefer discussions in this manner, over the internet. It allows for a more free-flowing of speech, less barriers, less awkwardness. It allows me to keep a distance between my real life and my life online. It sounds kinda mean and I don't mean it to be rude at all, it's just how I am.
Like I've said, I have no problem with serious online discussions either. In fact, I enjoy them when they're good