I was a huge fan back in the PP and NBC days - and the last few cd's were an awful slide backwards for the band, no doubt. I've been listening to the new cd for a week now and it isn't bad....it's certainly not on par with NBC, but it has some decent moments. I think one of the big obstacles they have is trying to overcome NBC - that cd had such great production and guitar playing and everything they have done since is inevitably compared to it. I think the drummer is the highlight of this release - Dirk Verbeuren did a great job on WD's cd, and he is solid on this one as well. The song "Epitome" at the start of this thread is a little weak - but his drumming saves it in my opinion.
Calling them the worst band ever seems a little short-sighted. Maybe they haven't been able to live up to the monster they created with NBC, but they are still a good melodic metal band. If you think posers like Bullet for My Valentine, Avenged Sevenfold, Linkin Park, etc are better - there is no point in arguing over it, you just hate them and won't like anything they ever do.