I think a lot of the shortcomings of the album can be attributed to the short production time (1 year). A lot of ideas were either left on the floor or sprinkled into V and the overall sound quality definitely could have been better.
One has to wonder how Twilight would have turned if given an extra year to produce it the way it was intended; possibly at the level many people hold DWoT and V to.
In any case, I still enjoy the album for what it is, and Looking Glass is probably my favorite song they've done live. They just seem to have the most fun and freedom with it.
I agree with this. It can be tough to compare this album to greats like Divine Wings and V, but if you take it for what it is, it's a great album. Also, TTLG is amazing on the album and even more incredible live. As much as I love Egypt, I was so happy when they played TTLG at the show I went to on the '08 PL tour (they were alternating those songs each night). It was even better than the LOTEOF version.
Anyway, as far as TIO goes, I pretty much love half of the album. Church of the Machine is such an underrated song, as is Orion (although it gets a little DT-ish in the solo section). The Relic is a good, fun, power metal cheese song that I think is better than most of their other songs of this type (the groove in the middle is nice).
Through the Looking Glass is a special song to me. I'm not sure why, but ever since the first listen I've loved every pretty much minute of it. But like a lot of the songs on this album, the solo section feels rushed and somewhat last-minute; with more time it could have been excellent.
The rest of the songs on the album aren't as high quality to me. Smoke and Mirrors may be one of the most overplayed songs in their catalog, and I've never understood why. Symphony X sure does love to play the first song on every album the most, don't they? Sonata is literally filler (you can tell it was so last-minute), and Dragon's Den is like The Relic but not as good (although the solos are nice). Finally, Lady of the Snow has
never clicked with me. Even on cold winter nights where it would seem like the perfect song to listen to, it doesn't do anything for me. And it has
nothing on Candlelight Fantasia.
At least nothing on this album is as filler as The Witching Hour, though.