Blackwater Park is far from being "the more beautiful album". What can they do next, after their 4th best album (that's how I rank BWP)? Well, they can go back to their former sound (I would die of fanboy-ism if this happened....but it won't) or they can do something completely different and mindblowing. If they stay on track and continue with the BWP/Deliverance "sound", then I think Opeth will finally fall from my grace once and for all...and I wouldn't feel sad; they've given us some amazing music in the past. In fact, I think the band might be at the end of their run, and quitting while you're ahead (Damnation) is a wise move....unless they come up with something completely mindblowing next, which would be a dream come true....but that seems unlikely, seeing as how Mikael promised something "very extreme" for the next album, which is basically the same thing he said about Deliverance.
Orchid, Morningrise and My Arms, Your Hearse are infinetely superior to BWP. They mop the floor with it.
I still LOVE Blackwater Park, but nothing has topped their first three albums, in my opinion.
Orchid and Morningrise have those beautiful dual guitar harmonies, and MAYH is one of the most atmospheric albums I have ever heard.
Blackwater Park is my favorite of their "new" phase/sound, and I'll always love it to death, but the Steven Wilson influence is almost overbearing.
Deliverance is by far their weakest album, at least to me. It feels incredibly disjointed, effortless and just half assed. And Steven Wilson's influence is even more blatant here (although he had more input on BWP). Deliverance is the only Opeth album I could live without....although A Fair Judgement still rocks my socks
Oh, and I love Porcupine Tree as well, but I just hope the next album will be Wilson-free...and maybe Opeth could go back to those amazing guitar harmonies OR try something completely different. Here's hoping for the latter