Your FAV'S: album wise

[Cerulean]

Well since everyone's posting Anathema top lists now...

1. Pentecost III
2. Eternity
3. The Silent Enigma
4. Alternative 4
5. Serenades
6. A Fine Day to Exit
7. A Natural Disaster
8. Judgement

The difference between 1 and 7 is not big though, and the order may vary from time to time.

 

[MadTinus]

The problem I have with Judgement is that it's just disgustingly cheesy, but that's nothing but an opinion... again
I love the title track though, and Emotional Winter's Pink Floyd rip off intro, and Forgotten Hopes is good too but it got old...
It just has a general fake atmosphere, and part of that is Dave Pybus' influence. He admitted after leaving Anathema that the stuff he wrote meant nothing to him, and he was just trying to write lyrics and music in Anathema's traditional style.
"No one seems to care anymore" Gimme a fecking break

I don't really see how Judgement is so much more cheesy than albums like A4 and Eternity.. Some of John's songs on the album are really good i.m.o. like "Don't Look Too Far", especially that part where the phrase "God bless this mess I'm in" is. He's a better songwriter than drummer (live at least..).

 

[derbeder]

1. Alternative 4
2. Eternity
3. A Natural Disaster
4. Judgement
5. A Nice Day to Exit
6. The Silent Enigma
7. Pentecost III
8. Serenades

 

[Swashbuckler]

Well... okay.

1. A Fine Day to Exit
2. Alternative 4
3. A Natural Disaster
4. Judgement
5. The Silent Enigma
6. Eternity
7. Serenades

 

[discouraged1]

1. Alternative 4
2. Eternity
3. Judgement
4. The Silent Enigma
5. Pentecost III
6. A Natural Disaster
7. A Fine Day To Exit
8. Serenades

 

[Cerulean]

I'm a stats freak so please let me do this with Katatonia as well

1. Brave Murder Day
2. The Great Cold Distance
3. Dance of December Souls
4. Discouraged Ones
5. Last Fair Deal Gone Down
6. Tonight's Decision
7. Viva Emptiness

A bit the same as with Anathema, all very close, except Viva Emptiness.

 

[MadTinus]

1. Last Fair Deal Gone Down
2. Brave Murder Day
3. Tonight's Decision
4. Discouraged Ones
5. The Great Cold Distance
6. Dance Of December Souls
7. Viva Emptiness

...all very close, except Viva Emptiness.

Fully agreed!

 

[stefan86]

1. Judgement
2. Alternative 4
3. The Silent Enigma
4. A Natural Disaster
5. Eternity
6. Pentecost III
7. Serenades
8. A Fine Day To Exit

-----------------------

1. Last Fair Deal Gone Down
2. Brave Murder Day
3. Tonight's Decision
4. Discouraged Ones
5. Viva Emptiness
6. Dance of December Souls
7. The Great Cold Distance

 

[Swashbuckler]

But, please, no Porcupine Tree top list.

1. Tonight's Decision
2. Viva Emptiness
3. The Great Cold Distance
4. Last Fair Deal Gone Down
5. Brave Murder Day
6. Discouraged Ones
7. Dance of December Souls

 

[stefan86]

Lets do top lists of every band in existance lawl!

 

[Cerulean]

Watch you words cos I'd do it.

 

[stefan86]

oh noez

 

[MadTinus]

Madonna:

- Like a Virgin
- True Blue
- You Can Dance
- all others, they'zz all saoooo greaaaaattt!! lol lol lawlz omg

Britney Spears

- can't decide, all of them!! she's soooooooo awessuuuummeee lol omg!!111 <3

 

[apaintedredlove]

Katatonia- Viva Emptiness
Porcupine Tree- On The Sunday of Life.

 

[Iivil]

It's too hard a job to put all Anathema's and Kata's albums in order, but my favourites are LFDGD and Alternative 4/Judgement (can't make up my mind). About Porcupine Tree I have no idea.

 

[Belligerent]

Porcupine tree list in full would be too hard.
Top 5:
Coma Divine (live)
Fear of A Blank Planet
The Sky Moves Sideways
In Absentia
Stupid Dream

 

[the mourner13]

Tonight's Decision
Discouraged Ones
Viva Emptiness
The Great Cold Distance
Last Fair Deal Gone Down
Brave Murder Day
Dance of December Souls
_________________________

A Natural Disaster
Alternative 4
Judgement
Eternity
Silent Enigma
A Fine Day to Exit
Serenades

 

[discouraged1]

i saw this coming

1. Viva Emptiness
2. Tonight's Decision
3. Last Fair Deal Gone Down
4. The Great Cold Distance
5. Discouraged Ones
6. Brave Murder Day
7. Dance Of December Souls

 

[Belligerent]

TGCD (by far the best)
Viva Emptiness
Tonights Decision
LFDGD
Discouraged Ones
BMD
Dance of Dec.

 

[MadTinus]

i saw this coming

...something bad..