Going by this logic, Rusty Cooley is a better guitarist than Steve Vai, and Frank Zappa is a terrible guitarist in comparison to both. This is obviously completely false.
I can only bear a few minutes of Rusty's mindless shred without getting ultra-bored, but I can watch Vai DVDs or listen to my Shut Up n' Play Yer Guitar trilogy all day long. Any good gitarist can shred, (anyone who's spent more than 10 minutes on Youtube knows this) but it takes a great guitarist to actually amaze me or inspire me.
No problem, the forum is getting quite slow so it's nice to see old members posting again. By the way, I was reading up on my movie thread a few days ago and rented Lady in the Water cause of your recommendation, it was fucking great!