- Jun 25, 2004
- 4,142
- 6
- 38
Actually, Black Sabbath, Iron Maiden, etc....all of the bands from then who influenced metal twenty years ago all the way to today. Guess what...they're STILL metal. AC/DC are not and have never been. They have always been arena rock-style stuff. They were heavy for their time, and I'm sure they have influenced metal bands, but that is not enough to call them metal themselves, in my opinion. Whereas most Black Sabbath songs, for instance, have compositional depth in the form of narrative structures or even just plain old epic/long songs with drawn-out instrumental sections (a big thing in metal and for the development of the instrumental capability prevalent in a lot of extreme metal, as well as the atmosphere of black metal, I would even say), AC/DC never did anything like this. They have always been verse-chorus-verse vanilla rock.
Again your going by todays standards and you are speaking as a fan of metal today. I grew up when AC/DC were considered Metal by all and that includes "metal" fans of yesteryear (yes the maiden,priest,sabbath etc. fans of those times). I have no doubt that if you grew up in the 70's and such you would of thought differently because that was the acceptance/train of thought of metal fans about AC/DC then. And there is no rules saying metal must be complex and cannot/should not do verse/chorus/verse song structures. Alot of the bands you do consider metal have used that structure and some still use it & have never changed. This is not about extreme metal which is the problem when people cannot consider anything metal unless it is extreme metal or influenced extreme metal. A rock influence in metal songs should not be excluded from calling it metal because metal is a versatile genre that takes many influences from many different types of music and makes it unique within the metal genre and that is what AC/DC did and Motorhead took to a further level afterwards.
With the exception of Sabbath, AC/DC were the heaviest band of their time until Motorhead came around in the mid to late 70's. AC/DC were simply pushed out of being considered metal at that point but that doesn't mean they weren't a new metal band for a new genre called metal in the early 70's to begin with. They simply became a mainstream metal band with the release of Highway to Hell and/or Back in Black.
And I would have to agree with Vihris & King Richard that at the very least AC/DC is borderline or in the grey area in this issue.