FauxPerspicacity said:I'm an agnostic but I like the Jewish ideals such as studying not necessarily Torah but just persuing truth. What pisses me off about a lot of Jews though is that they basically follow a Jesus-less Christianity with different holidays and traditions and have no idea what real Jewish ideals are. Believing and following a 'god' is not the main issue as I have come to understand it. A number of Jews are actually atheists. Of course I'm mainly referring to Reform Judaism.
However the way I define religion is that it's essentially a set of beliefs. Everyone has a set of beliefs and everyones beliefs are different. So the whole 'church and state' issue is ridiculous as well are atheists that claim to oppose all religions.
This is just my viewpoint of course.
egonomic666 said:im spiritual which means i beleive in a god or a higher power but i follow no specific religion itake the lessons taught and applie them so i live a good life thats it, ( my family is all christian so i celebrate christmas)
lord667 said:All religions are beliefs, but not all beliefs are religions. The church and state issue is important because the idealised purpose of a government is to serve the earthly welfare of the people, not to impose "God's word" upon them. Lastly, your beef with atheism is only logical working from your definition of a "religion", which isn't correct. A "religion" is a belief system derived from the diktats of a supernatural entity or spiritual guru. So atheism is, by definition, not a religion, but rather a school of theology.
FauxPerspicacity said:Yeah i guess i was wrong about the definition of religion but it's sort of a word that can be defined differently depending upon the perspective.
As for the 'church and state' issue "God's word" dictates that we should not kill, not steal, and what have you. So how could a country make laws as such that are not based on "God's word". And let's say someone's religion believes in murder or human sacrifice or something along those lines should they be arrested? Of course that's just a for instance.
lord667 said:I'm not saying that countries should deliberately exclude everything that any religion says. That would be absurd. But laws against murder and theft are NOT necessarily based on "God's Word". Even a 100% atheist society where nobody had ever even heard of God would recognise that not letting people kill each other on a whim is quite important for peace and order.QUOTE]
I completely agree that a person doesn't need "God" to know whats right, and a lot of people don't need "God" to do whats right. But I also believe a weak society needs a god to inflict consequences otherwise I bet a simple minded people couldn't function if they knew their were no ultimate consequences.
Now this is just my opinion, but I think a main reason why America is pro Israel is because our leader is a Christian. In the Bible it says that the Jews are in Israel at the end of the world where they can be eliminated for their sins. Of course it seems to be popular in America to be pro Israel anyway.
Hey why didn't the quote work