karelrulez
Member
#1 Michael Romeo
#2 John Petrucci
I don't have a problem with this list at all..??
no wait.. that's the REAL one..
#2 John Petrucci
I don't have a problem with this list at all..??
no wait.. that's the REAL one..
Anyone see this joke of a list yet?
- Thread starter Platinum Maze
- Start date
Yngvai X
Dark Emperor
The Stormbringer said:
DT are popular with/and Petrucci is recognized as a virtuoso by prog musicians and guitar geeks, nothing more. At least here in America. I would never call them a popular band, since that implies mainstream popularity. They have a strong cult following and thats it.
The Metal Chick
In the Dragon's Den
It´s guitar geeks who should do this list... sadly, that´s not the case, so we have Kirk Hammet and Kurt Cobain among the world´s best guitarists.Yngvai X said:
EDIT: fixed an evil, embarrasing typo.
karelrulez
Member
The Metal Chick said:hehe we should make our own list since we know what it should really be.
sorry sorry I didn't really mean it that way like I know exactly who are the best guitar players
but that would have been alot better I think
The Metal Chick
In the Dragon's Den
karelrulez said:sorry sorry I didn't really mean it that way like I know exactly who are the best guitar players
You DO know who are the best. I was agreeing with you.
SilentRealm
Member
I agree with Amanda though we should make our own list of the best guitarists based on who we know of. And I think prog musicians are more qualified than the people of Rolling Stone Magazine to answer that because they have heard a wide range of music, especially metal where it's the bands business to have fantastic talent.
Mr. Shred-ididle
Its Chinese-Tilt ya' head
- Jan 25, 2003
- 1,701
- 6
- 38
- 35
1. Greg Howe (GENIUS)
2. Mike Romeo
3. Tony MacAlpine
4. Frank Gambale
5. Allan Holdswoth
6. JP
7. Jason Becker
and on and on . . . .
2. Mike Romeo
3. Tony MacAlpine
4. Frank Gambale
5. Allan Holdswoth
6. JP
7. Jason Becker
and on and on . . . .
'Shuggah
So sweet?
Platinum Maze said:
LOL!
ROFLMAO!
OMG!
Yeah. It's a pretty ridiculous list.
At least there was one finn on the list, though.
karelrulez
Member
[QUOTE='Shuggah]LOL!
ROFLMAO!
OMG!
Yeah. It's a pretty ridiculous list. At least there was one finn on the list, though. [/QUOTE]
Tom Morello? I actually think he's pretty good
ROFLMAO!
OMG!
Yeah. It's a pretty ridiculous list.
At least there was one finn on the list, though. [/QUOTE]Tom Morello? I actually think he's pretty good
'Shuggah
So sweet?
karelrulez said:Tom Morello? I actually think he's pretty good
As far as I know, he doesn't have the chops to match his arsenal of effects. But that's just my opinion. I've listened to too much prog anyway.
DestrwidoR
Erunér - One of The Seven
WTF!?
What a shit list...
Rollin' Stone sucks!
And, man, I know some people who thinks "Kirk Hammett is the best ever!!!", they look to this kind of list and say: "Man, this is wrong, Kirk's number is #1"
I don''t know if I cry or laugh!
and I'm so happy to be a Guitar Geek!
What a shit list...
Rollin' Stone sucks!
And, man, I know some people who thinks "Kirk Hammett is the best ever!!!", they look to this kind of list and say: "Man, this is wrong, Kirk's number is #1"
I don''t know if I cry or laugh!
and I'm so happy to be a Guitar Geek!
DestrwidoR
Erunér - One of The Seven
RequiemX
King of Ithaca
I have a little list of my own:
Top 5 Worst Music Magazines
1. Rolling Stone
2. Rolling Stone
3. Rolling Stone
4. Rolling Stone
5. Rolling Stone
Wait...guys! Don't stuff the ballot box!
Top 5 Worst Music Magazines
1. Rolling Stone
2. Rolling Stone
3. Rolling Stone
4. Rolling Stone
5. Rolling Stone
Wait...guys! Don't stuff the ballot box!
Kate Bush Rules!
Kali Yuga
Yeah it was a terrible list, i mean where the fuck was John McLaughlin. Only guitarists who wrote catchy blues-rock songs got on that list.
[QUOTE='Shuggah]LOL!
ROFLMAO!
OMG!
Yeah. It's a pretty ridiculous list. At least there was one finn on the list, though. [/QUOTE]
All those guitarists are good, except for Kurt Cobain.
[QUOTE='Shuggah]LOL!
ROFLMAO!
OMG!
Yeah. It's a pretty ridiculous list.
At least there was one finn on the list, though. [/QUOTE]All those guitarists are good, except for Kurt Cobain.
Classical, Jazz and fusion require more talent and knowledge to play than metal does.SilentRealm said:
'Shuggah
So sweet?
Quoting the band T-shirt of a certain finnish band: "You are wrong - Disappear!"
I guess I am not eligible for an opinion, am I?
I guess I am not eligible for an opinion, am I?
ElPredicador
Yeah... Whatever
I think for the first time I will agree with KBR: classical, jazz and fusion players are more talented than metal players
[QUOTE='Shuggah]LOL!
ROFLMAO!
OMG!
Yeah. It's a pretty ridiculous list. At least there was one finn on the list, though. [/QUOTE]
Shuggah, I completely agree with you. Those rankings are ridiculous. Kim Thayil should be ranked WAY higher.
ROFLMAO!
OMG!
Yeah. It's a pretty ridiculous list.
At least there was one finn on the list, though. [/QUOTE]Shuggah, I completely agree with you. Those rankings are ridiculous. Kim Thayil should be ranked WAY higher.
Cyclopssss
Member
Snowmaker
GO BLUE!!
Knight of the Templar said:#17 - Jack White of The White Stripes?!?!?!?! !
WTF?!
That list is pure crap. It's Rolling Stone. Equal of MTV in music bussiness.... yeah, sure... Jack White is faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar better than Blackmore, and Romeo... yeah, sure.... he can do a lot of incredible stuff with his guitar.... yeah, sure...
That pissed me off. If that imp is 17... dammit!
You beat me to that one. I like their CD, but there is no way in hell he should be on that list.
Similar threads
