April Ethereal vs When

[Led Opeth]

yea when is my favorite opeth song, i just wanted to cut against the grain...but that riff owns thats why Æ got my pick

 

[Pethical]

I like to take AE and When together, but this is about if we had to choose one, which is why i chose when, like many others.

 

[Detric]

April Ethereal

 

[Gramm]

1 vote for april ethereal. Simply because it was the one I heard first and it brings back good memories

When is not a bad song at all. Love it. It just doesn't have the same meaning to me as april ethereal has.

 

[dishcloth]

no, im suggesting that When owns the shit out of AE, altough AE is still an amazing song.

April Ethreal easily. I don't understand this sense of awesomeness people have towards When. Sure its a good song, but it is only that. Just a good song.

 

[Sickman]

april ethereal....go to 6:00 for my reason

I voted for April Ethereal, but that's actually my least favorite part of the song. The part following it at 6:45 is great, but the prior part just doesn't seem to fit the rest of the song to me.

 

[Rocky Raccoon]

Still.. When is kicking Aprils ass

 

[dishcloth]

True. It's probably just me who can't see what the fuss is about with When. I guess some songs just suit some people better...

 

[7th Spade]

I like AE, I really do, but when I get to about 1:25 into When my vote is cast. It really sets the mood for the rest of the song. And although AE has a kickass outro, When is better as a whole song IMO.

 

[saut]

imo

 

[Yoda]

thats not fair.

i went with april ethereal just because the rain was waving goodbye part.

That would be what would sway me. But I say When.

 

[My Arms, Your Purse]

Æ is my all-time Opeth favourite song, so I quite naturally voted for it ;D