April Ethereal vs When

[7th Spade]

I really thought I was going to vote April Ethereal on this one but after just listening to both of them I'd have to go with When.

 

[worldwide_suicide]

easy one... WHEN!

 

[~random~]

I can't decide...sorry, I just can't do it.

 

[Maggot9]

I like April Ethereal better as a song. The only part i REALLY like in When is at the end when he sings the "Chorus" so to speak.

 

[Endar]

The two are really great but When can't be beaten there ! The Intro is so intense and the outro is totally unbeatable

 

[in limbow]

When is slightly better

 

[biggsy]

looks like when wins... what a pity

 

[WTF555666]

April Ethereal

 

[Maggai]

Both amazing songs. And sort of different. I think i like April ethereal a little bit more. It's a perfect song. But so is when. Hmmmm this is hard.

 

[TheButcher]

April Ethereal

 

[King Richard]

Just for the hell of it...



SHIT THREAD LOL

 

[opethXisXlove916]

thats a toughieeeee

i'm gonna have to say

April Ethereal!

 

[King Richard]

You lose.

 

[deliverancelolingatme]

thats a toughieeeee

i'm gonna have to say

April Ethereal!

how does this not surprise me?

 

[opethXisXlove916]

how does this not surprise me?

uhmm.. what?
are you suggesting April Ethereal is a shit song?

 

[neilyoungfan]

when


.

 

[Blackwater_Deth]

easily When!!!! the ending is just amazing

 

[deliverancelolingatme]

uhmm.. what?
are you suggesting April Ethereal is a shit song?

no, im suggesting that When owns the shit out of AE, altough AE is still an amazing song.

 

[Led Opeth]

april ethereal....go to 6:00 for my reason

 

[deliverancelolingatme]

great riff led opeth, but sry, doesnt quite cut it. when > ae.