Well a few days later, and Ive totally thrashed this album out.
What can I say? A masterpiece in its own right, and an essential album for any Black Metal enthusiast. When looking back at the times, and considering it hails from America, I think the album is quite unique. Its on high rotation on the iPod
As for my friend... I made him listen to the title track in its entirety, trying to point out things as it went along. His opinion has changed, but I hope he sees what I see in it. I trust his intuition though, he's pretty musically switched on (I owe my obsession with Tåke to him).
As for the Emperor-ness... I'm suprised an Emperor fan might not like it... it definitely heralds the Wrath of the Tyrant and (lesser extent) In The Nightside Eclipse age of Emperor.
In summary, the more I listen to Weakling, the more I like it. Definitely one to order through the local metalshop when I get the chance, an essential album both musically and historically.