Ken Lyall
Member
cool man,Tubbs Mcgee said:
don't get stressed?
Rush, to me are probabily better than floyd. It depends on the time and date of the question
Maybe not, listened to both for 30 years, still not made my mind up
Best Floyd?
- Thread starter Detric
- Start date
don't get stressed?
Rush, to me are probabily better than floyd. It depends on the time and date of the question
Maybe not, listened to both for 30 years, still not made my mind up
Scourge of Malice
Member
I'll say "Meddle" just because it has "Echoes" which is my all time favorite song by any band. The rest of the album is great as well but that song is just orgasmic. They all have their moments. I've actually gotten back into them lately and have been rediscovering "Animals."
Ken Lyall
Member
Tubbs
Bi-weekly top album:
I'm not stressed, I was just wondering whether you were being sarcastic or not.Ken Lyall said:cool man,
don't get stressed?
Rush, to me are probabily better than floyd. It depends on the time and date of the question
Maybe not, listened to both for 30 years, still not made my mind up
(Like I was being before! Sorry about that.)
Ken Lyall
Member
Maybe a little, sorry,
PF are excellent, except for final cut. Rush are there also. I was at secondary school when Hemispheres was released, lucy me.
Anyhow, sorry to pick on you,
PF are excellent, except for final cut. Rush are there also. I was at secondary school when Hemispheres was released, lucy me.
Anyhow, sorry to pick on you,
Tubbs
Bi-weekly top album:
Don Corleone
Emre
Lord Byron said:The Final Cut....thats just bollocks
i can easily understand why most people dont dig that album...
but i like it. not as much as the others maybe, but it's a really dark, mature album...proper waters stuff =) i remember duncan patterson's comparison of this album to gilmour's solo stuff a year or two back..."man against boys" hahaha he's strictly pro-waters, so this view is a bit sided and the comment a bit exaggerated, but he does have a point there.
in conclusion, i like the final cut. cmon, you at least have to give credit to those amazing lyrics or at least the "one of the few" track
GET YOUR FILTHY HANDS OFF MY DESERT!! :Smug:
Don Corleone
Emre
twilightsrobe
evil eye
I find Obscured By Clouds an excellent album often overlooked by many!
Anyone attending the Roger Waters tour dates? I've already acquired my tickets for Boston!
Anyone attending the Roger Waters tour dates? I've already acquired my tickets for Boston!
Abhorsen
Long Distance Voyager
Abhorsen
Long Distance Voyager
I think Waters and Gilmour need each other. Their strengths compliment one another. Waters' solo output lacks the melody and atmosphere that Gilmour's playing brings and the Division Bell and Momentary Lapse lack Waters' excellent lyrical ability and sound a little retro, though still pleasant.
Abhorsen
Long Distance Voyager
I should add though that Gilmour's latest solo record is really fantastic and lacks for nothing.
![[KOTNO]Narrot](/data/avatars/l/1/1031.jpg?1052155060){kind=avatar}
[KOTNO]Narrot
Eats and spits corpses...
i like 'wish you were here most' but 'animals', DSOTM, Meddle and ASOS are not far behind.
and i think PF really sucked after animals ...
and i think PF really sucked after animals ...
Don Corleone
Emre
kevin_cfh said:Waters
He's nothing without Gilmour.
Animals
Wish You Were Here
Meddle
The Division Bell
Dark Side
you are an idiot. do you actually know ANYTHING about writing a song, coming up with lyrics and such?
animals, wish you were here and the dark side's most songs were written by waters.
again, you are an idiot. learn to appreciate musicianship before posting smilies of that sort.
Lord Byron
My Uncle Is A Retard
Don Corleone said:
He does have a point though. Waters music is very harsh without the sense of atmosphere and melody that Gilmour brings. Saying that though i love both of them equally. Im going to the Roger Waters concert here next month. I cant wait to see one of my heroes in concert!!
Edit: OMFG i hope he plays Each Small Candle!!!!! Now that is an amazing piece of musicianship.....*drools*
Similar threads
