@TageRyche
God Loves, Man Kills is a classic. I'm a huge fan of Claremonts X-Men.
claremont is actually a good superhero writer
but we have to acknowledge the fact that a huge amount of people who call themselves "X-men fans" are ONLY fans of Claremont's run
and the end of the day we have to acknowledge the fact that a huge part of what makes claremont's x-men seem so fucking awesome is the fact that everyone else who writes x-men comics totally sucks at it
as evidence of the non-claremont x-men writers sucking i present this
Cyclops: the Worst Leader (an interview) - Take up your scythe
in this "interveiw" the character cyclops is actually accurately describing the parts of the x-men comic that were not written by cris claremont
the only part of this horrible history that claremont wrote was "the death of jean grey"
this wasn't even claremont's decision "jean grey must die" was an instruction from editorial
claremont realized that cyclops had been dating jean grey for the entire history of the 2 characters
and with her death, claremont decided to give scott summers a brand-new girl-friend
claremont was okay with the artist's idea of having cyclops date a new character that looked just like jean grey
but jean's look-alike being jean's clone was something that claremont knew nothing about until after he'd been moved off of the x-men title
(IIRC claremon't last issue as writer was just a couple of issues after madylyn pryor's very first appearance)
and claremont has repeatedly said in multiple interviews that he intended pryor to be a regular person and that he totally hated the idea of madylyn pryor being a clone
all the horrible shit in the link i posted above is describing people other that claremont fucking up the comic
claremont's a good writer but he looks like the greatest writer in all of superheros because all the other people writing X-men comics just totally suck at writing X-men comics (weirdly including a guy who was good at writing Avengers comics)