paradoxile said:
The BM scene in Norway wasn't nazi at first...it was more of a nature and paganism oriented as an alternative to the boring world of christianity.
so I don't buy turning Nazi due to "peer prussure" as an excuse...
Varg's success was more because the media made a martyr out of him and as far as I know Jon Nödveidt wasn't a nazi, he was a satanist.
I mostly agree with you on the fact that BM music of those days(that would be the 90's) would make less of an appeal to today's audience but you neglected the fact that as the people who listen to the music progress so does the artist. I didn't listen to Reignkaos(because I don't support gay bashers and murderers that also means I haven't heard any of Burzum's music for the same reason) but I watched people here in UM praise it...I never heard anyone saying it's shit so I'm guessing it did pretty well.
now back to the point Jon could return after 7 or 8 years in prison and make a great album so why can't Varg?
I don't think Jon's suicide had anything to do with his place in today's music...it's probably that satanic stuff that drove him insane,or a chrisis of faith(his faith anyway)
I think that in fact, part of the Norwegian black metal scene as we know it DID start off with white supremacist undertones. Jon wasn't a racist? Well, he was a bigot and was involved in the murder of a gay immigrant. He wasn't a National Socialist, but he wasn't the most progressive guy, either. I have a Swedish friend here who once remarked that a lot of the mythology that's been used in heavy Scandinavian music is part of a nationalistic appeal that it has... maybe to us on the outside, Thor is just a cool guy who swings a hammer and tosses lightning bolts, but to some racialists (hey, among them American white supremacists) Thor embodies the ideal "Nordic" man.
I guess you're sort of defining white supremacy as more narrowly a Nazi phenomenon. What I'm saying is that Burzum is a Nazi because he was in a music scene that had a lot of people who were ideologically racists in its early days. And the people I've heard this from are Swedes. I haven't had a chance to read Lords of Chaos, but a friend of mine said that book touches on this subject; if I wasn't busy reading a million books every day, I'd take some time to look at it myself.
To sum it up, I think when we get on a guy like Burzum's case, we have to remember the Emperor guys named a side project after Cynide pills used to gas Jews, and Jon asks vaguely in Storm of the Light's Bane to "allow me to erase your feeble race." I'm not saying that people don't change their mind when they get older (there's a reason there used to be a disclaimer on Zyklon's site saying that they did not support discrimination in any form). My point was that Jon and Burzum went to jail pretty early on; when they got out, not only was their music passed by, but also the vaguely white supremacist tone of the scene.
Maybe that's just me thinking aloud about it. As a metalhead, I'd rather be honest that things were not so peachy back in the day (especially being a minority myself, although most people wouldn't guess it since I look like a midwestern farm boy). Don't want to end up like my friends who listen to rap, who try to justify pimping, mysogeny, macho insecurity and criminality to me since it's had a central element in mainstream commercial rap music and culture (not suggesting in the least all rap is like that, of course).