monoxide_child
New Metal Member
- Jul 30, 2008
- 6,210
- 4
- 0
My list of great comic to film movies.
The Rocketeer: Great popcorn movie, good fun, and its got Jennifer Connely (hubba hubba)
Superman 1&2
Spiderman
X-Men
Road To Perdition, did ya know this was a "graphic novel" long before it was a movie?
The Mask introducing the world to Cameron Diaz/ Jim Carry was perfect.
Men in Black: not one of my favorites but it worked as a film.
Ghost World: small little film,very good
Blade: the first one was cool
And the sucky ones:
Judge Dredd
The Phantom
The Shadow
all Batman (even the first one doesnt to Batman justice.)
Superman W/ Richard Pryor WTH???
Barb Wire
The Crow
Teenage Muntant Ninja Turtles
The Punisher
Captain America: he had rubber ears....
Howard the Duck:dear God...
Swamp Thing/ should have been an acid trip thriller not campy fluff
Virus: Jamie Lee Curtis/ obscure Dark Horse comic book.
i am a huge Marvel comics fan, and i know a lot about DC
and i have to disagree a little bit with these lists
my list of Great Comic Book Movies
CAPTAIN AMERICA (the brand new one)
PUNISHER (Thomas Jane one)
WATCHMEN
when i saw the movie Watchmen, it really seemed like Alan Moore had made a ton of mistakes and Zack Snyder fixed them
BATMAN BEGINS
i know i'll get flack for this, but i gotta say it,
Batman Begins >>>>>>>>>>>> The Dark Knight
THE PHANTOM and THE SHADOW and THE ROCKETEER
i think most of the young people who thought these movies sucked, would have prefered them to be done as "modernized re-imaginings", but I watched them as "period peices" and when veiwed as such, i felt like those 3 movies were really well made
DAREDEVIL
i know a lot of people on ultimate metal (other forums, not just this one) got exited about Daredevil getting re-booted because they hated the first one so much, i really don't see why, before the movie, i knew Daredevil as a guest character in Amazing Spiderman, Punisher comic, and the Fantastic Four, so i really didn't notice any of the differences between the movie and the comic, Daredevil's costume is leather instead of spandex, there's no spandex in the movie, Bullseye wears streetclothes instead of a costume, and the character Kingpin (that i knew from spiderman and punisher comics) was played by an actual actor, instead of a proffesional wrestler as i had totally expected, so i don't really see how anyone could say this movie sucked
BLADE TRILOGY
i never really understood all the big debates about which movie in this trilogy was the best/worst, i thought they were all pretty good
THE CROW
was decent, not really awesome, but it shouldn't be on anyone's Worst movie list either
SWAMP THING
it's pretty cool if you walk in expecting it to be "campy fluff" Troma doesn't made thriller movies
okay now for THE CRAPPY SUPERHERO MOVIE LIST
CAPTAIN AMERICA (the older one)
PUNISHER (Dolf lundgren one)
SPIDERMAN 3
it's so crappy, it makes the first 2 look awesome by comparison
SUPERMAN MOVIES (Christopher Reaves and Brandon Routh)
i hated the way they did Clark Kent, although, i can apretiate how awesome of an actor Routh was for being able to amazingly perfectly copy something that i hated when i saw it 20 years earlier
i didn't put Punisher Warzone/Thor/Green Lantern on either list because i haven't seen them
also
MIB, Howard the Duck, and Ghostworld WEREN'T superhero movies
and The Mask is a comedy, where as the other Superhero movies weren't