sometimes i feel and think that even AJFA was a shit...
Even though I slightly prefer Master of Puppets, And Justice for All is the Metallica album that I listen to the most because it never gets old for me. While most people, including the band for god's sake, hate the production - I love it. In fact, it has my all time favorite guitar sound. It just so damn crunchy...
As far as the new album, the production is it's weakest link. The entire album is right at or above the clipping level. I don't get it how a producer like Rick Rubin can screw that up. I understand that artists want to record their albums "louder" and "louder" so that they will stand out on the radio and supposedly sound better...
Other than that I am REALLY liking this album. 7 of the 10 songs are doing it for me right now. # 1,2, and 4 are the only mediocre songs for me right now. I'll take that any day, 7 songs that I like a lot. My favorites right now are All Nightmare Long, Unforgiven III, and I love the middle section of the instrumental.
I do wish they could give me some more crunch and completely do away with that twangy Loadish sounding guitar, but overall I am very impressed with this album.
One last question thing - why do they love to release the the worst song on their albums (Until it Sleeps, Fuel, The Memory Remains, St. Anger, The Day that Never Comes).