Just so you know I'm not totally against you making some money off this. I understand that you bought the extra ticket and it is yours to do with as you wish. However, I wouldn't say you are in your "right" to sell the ticket for more than face value, since scalpping is illegal. I certainly wouldn't expect you to give the ticket away though. That would be unfair to you. And as much as I don't like the idea of selling a ticket for more than face value, I understand that perhaps you want money for the mailing cost, whatever services charges you initially paid, and perhaps a little extra for your time and effort to sell the ticket.
It did bother me, however, that you seemed to be getting pleasure out of several others' unfortunate situations and the bidding war that you were instigating among a group of fans/friends. (You may not consider the people on here friends, but many of us do.)
Moreover, You also seemed to get a kick out of the fact that you could make people hold out for several months, while they beg and plead with you via email and the forum for them to be the one you select. Had you offered up the ticket, taken a few days to give everyone a chance to make you their offers and then given those folks your final decission, I wouldn't have cared if someone gave you $1000 and a truck of beer. (I would have thought they were a little crazy, but it's their money.) But instead, I think you're enjoying the anxiety that you are putting those bidders through and now you just want to milk it for everything you can.
In short - I'm not against making money. I'm against being a jerk. :Smug:
I'm glad to see you say this. And I think it's honorable of you to have re-thought your stance on the situation. I hope whoever you decide to give the ticket to will appriciate it (and I'm pretty certain they will). Rock on!