GMD Poll: Top 10 Metal Albums of 2003

[-CC-]

Man only that BAN album is even worthy of being mentioned. No one cares about Runemagick's 4th best album or that fucking turd Crimson II.

Clearly. The forum has spoken.

This vote reminded me of the Presidential election. Except, I'm not sure which outcome worries me more.

 

[CiG]

"While Heaven Wept is vile, saccharine crap. I'm amazed that such credible people as you and Rich Walker actually pay credence to these compositionally incompetent musicians." - Dodens Grav

This guy might be the biggest loser I've ever heard of.

No Runemagick, no Blut Aus Nord, no Crimson II.

 

[The Ozzman]

Holy shit, this year's top 10 was abysmal. I still have to listen to a few of them, but I just listened to that Doomsword record (#7) twice, and how did such a mediocre album beat out some legendary albums of this year? It wasn't bad or anything, just completely meh.

No Runemagick, no Blut Aus Nord, no Crimson II. Is this why Bitencourt left the forums?

I haven't listened to anything listed in the Top 10. Shit poll 0/10

 

[-CC-]

While Heaven Wept has the best selection of quotes yet

 

[CiG]

But it still won and your shitty albums didn't.

I haven't listened to anything listed in the Top 10. Shit poll 0/10

Perfect opportunity to check some new stuff out then.

 

[The Ozzman]

But it still won and your shitty albums didn't.



Perfect opportunity to check some new stuff out then.

I actually think I've listened to that Drudkh album now that I read the list again but I don't get they hype behind that band although I like the band.

Just reinforces my point that GMD is nothing but a mostly doom/trad circle jerk these days

 

[CiG]

Well, it was 2003.

 

[H.P. Lovecraft]

This guy might be the biggest loser I've ever heard of.

Instead of "run" does Dodens bend his girls over the loveseat and make them spell "pretentious artard"?

 

[no country for old wainds]

i haven't heard crimson II but if it's anything like crimson I, no thx. i'd have been ok with BaN making it though. i got burnt out on it pretty quickly when it was released and rarely revisit it, but it's pretty cool for what it is. better than some of the other AOTW BM fads of that era.

never heard the runemagick but i seriously doubt it would've made the list in any era of this board. you can bet enslaved would've made it back in the day.

 

[HamburgerBoy]

This guy might be the biggest loser I've ever heard of.

lmao overlooked that one. Classic Dodens.

I mean I hate WHW as well but it's the way he says it.

 

[Mort Divine]

Traveller definitely deserves it.

 

[Vilden]

What's up with the WHW hate? It's a great record, the kind of record you listen to while home alone, looking out the window while sipping on a stiff drink or something. It might be cheesy but I think they manage to sound convincing. I get alot more moody listening to Of Empires Forlorn than some whiny Warning (which I also like ofcourse).

I think Traveller as #1 is way overrating, but I guess it is ok as this board just fellates on Slough Feg generally, I mean they are good and all, but not the second coming of Iron Maiden or anything.

 

[CiG]

What do you have against Slough Feg?

For a band so original yet mired in metal history to come out of nowhere in the late 90's and do what they've done and still are doing. Top 5 band for me and always will be.

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

Top 5 band for me and always will be.

that top 5 rotates based upon what bands the poseur crowd is currently circle jerking to. I've already seen you post over a hundred bands as your TOP 5 or 10 favorites. get a hold of yourself son.

 

[CiG]

My top 5 is firmly set in place and it's even in order.

1. The Dubliners (forever my favourite band ever)
2. Manilla Road
3. Saint Vitus
4. Bolt Thrower
5. Slough Feg

 

[Vilden]

What do you have against Slough Feg?

For a band so original yet mired in metal history to come out of nowhere in the late 90's and do what they've done and still are doing. Top 5 band for me and always will be.

Nothing at all really, I own several of their albums and even listed Traveller in my top 10 here. I would never list them anywhere near a list of best bands ever though. Guess it is a bit of backlash agaist some peoples (like you ) preposterous overrating.

 

[CiG]

Somehow I doubt that.

 

[Einherjar86]

Why the fuck did I feel the need to specify that I owned Of Empires Forlorn? Does that somehow increase the legitimacy of my opinion about it?

Whatever, it is an awesome record, fuck the haters.

 

[Bloopy]

I actually think I've listened to that Drudkh album now that I read the list again but I don't get they hype behind that band although I like the band.

Just reinforces my point that GMD is nothing but a mostly doom/trad circle jerk these days

Doom & trad are among my favourite subgenres and yet the only album from the top 10 I've heard in full is DoomSword's. But then my typical experience with bands is skipping forward into a song and dismissing them after 5s because I don't care for the vocals.

 

[Mort Divine]

I actually think I've listened to that Drudkh album now that I read the list again but I don't get they hype behind that band although I like the band.

Just reinforces my point that GMD is nothing but a mostly doom/trad circle jerk these days

its ok you can always just listen to devildriver if good music is beyond your ken