Serjeant Grumbles
Active Member
- Mar 20, 2005
- 4,385
- 2,834
- 113
If Mort Divine ruled the world
- Thread starter Zephyrus
- Start date
arg
Active Member
- Jun 4, 2008
- 5,747
- 1,437
- 113
the yoga industrial complex. now ive heard everything
http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2018/...remacy/?utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=social
http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2018/...remacy/?utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=social
Dak
mentat
You either appropriate or perpetuate oppressive white culture. You should know by now these are the only two options.
Oblivious Maximus
I am the worm
CiG
Coming of Age in the Milky Way
Surely you're not too drunk to follow the sources provided within the article: http://www.kzoo.edu/praxis/yoga/
Onder
Active Member
- Apr 10, 2006
- 11,389
- 2,029
- 113
CiG
Coming of Age in the Milky Way
Einherjar86
Active Member
But Onder's right that it still is Breibart, and Breitbart published that article with a very specific purpose in mind: to infuriate its readers that the liberal elite is once again claiming white hegemony and colonialism and trying to outlaw something as innocuous as yoga.
These kinds of academic arguments aren't calls for the removal or prohibition of certain activities (in this case yoga). They might provoke disagreement and eye rolls, but they're not calls to arms. Despite the lack of any specific language, Breitbart is being slightly disingenuous in that its publishers know full well what their readers' reactions will be, and those reactions will be mostly incommensurate with the purpose of the academic argument. The original authors aren't asking people to stop doing yoga, just the opposite in fact:
The point of academic arguments like this is to contribute to discourse and knowledge, and that means necessitates the publication of pieces that we don't agree with and that deserve critique. Breitbart is capitalizing on its readers' fury over these kinds of arguments, and stoking the belief that liberal elites are trying to thought-police the West. But nothing in the original piece encourages legislation or anything even remotely as vitriolic as some pieces we find on Salon. It's merely asking people to reflect on something they probably don't think about very much.
But let's be honest, the vast majority of white Americans who practice yoga probably won't ever hear about this piece; and I kinda doubt that many of Breitbart's readers practice yoga.
But that's me being presumptuous.
These kinds of academic arguments aren't calls for the removal or prohibition of certain activities (in this case yoga). They might provoke disagreement and eye rolls, but they're not calls to arms. Despite the lack of any specific language, Breitbart is being slightly disingenuous in that its publishers know full well what their readers' reactions will be, and those reactions will be mostly incommensurate with the purpose of the academic argument. The original authors aren't asking people to stop doing yoga, just the opposite in fact:
The point of academic arguments like this is to contribute to discourse and knowledge, and that means necessitates the publication of pieces that we don't agree with and that deserve critique. Breitbart is capitalizing on its readers' fury over these kinds of arguments, and stoking the belief that liberal elites are trying to thought-police the West. But nothing in the original piece encourages legislation or anything even remotely as vitriolic as some pieces we find on Salon. It's merely asking people to reflect on something they probably don't think about very much.
But let's be honest, the vast majority of white Americans who practice yoga probably won't ever hear about this piece; and I kinda doubt that many of Breitbart's readers practice yoga.
But that's me being presumptuous.
CiG
Coming of Age in the Milky Way
The media do almost nothing other than produce vapid outrage news and articles that give its audience a fake feeling of superiority.
For example, FOX just gave us this gem: Woman denied emotional support peacock on United flight, which plays into the idea that there is an over sensitive problem and it's on the left (which gives the right a feeling of being stoic and tough when actually they're just as PC and snowflakey as the left).
Then today Facebook was trending articles about how Donald Trump has done another typo: Donald Trump: Typo on tickets invites people to 'State of the Uniom'.
Pointless drivel, no better or worse than an academic or two spurting out articles about whites doing yoga.
But let's be honest, the vast majority of white Americans who practice yoga probably won't ever hear about this piece; and I kinda doubt that many of Breitbart's readers practice yoga.
Agreed.
Dak
mentat
Because the Lululemon and smoothie crowd thinks the Swedes invented Yoga? I'm not sure who is "enlightened" by such pieces.
But let's be honest, the vast majority of white Americans who practice yoga probably won't ever hear about this piece; and I kinda doubt that many of Breitbart's readers practice yoga.
This is the irony in the whole thing. But on the other hand, it just gets added to the ever growing list of racist/problematic/etc things.
Einherjar86
Active Member
Well, I am for one, but it has nothing to do with who started yoga. I'm also interested in research on the cultural fascination and dissemination of rap music among white middle-class Americans, but that's not because I'm unaware that rap emerged within poor black urban neighborhoods.
Shreena Gandhi's dissertation is actually on the history of yoga's dissemination in America, to whom it was marketed and by whom it was embraced, which goes back to American Transcendentalism in the nineteenth century.
I never knew that...
Dak
mentat
Well I think Sowell would claim there's a bit of reciprocal nature to this exchange, mediated by many decades, via his arguments about the roots of African American culture origins in Black Rednecks and White Liberals.
Shreena Gandhi's dissertation is actually on the history of yoga's dissemination in America, to whom it was marketed and by whom it was embraced, which goes back to American Transcendentalism in the nineteenth century.
That is slightly surprising, and of course cultural contact of the times was colonial in nature. But the sincerest form of flattery is imitation.
rms
Active Member
Einherjar86
Active Member
CiG
Coming of Age in the Milky Way
I think one of the deep ironies of the whole anti-"cultural appropriation" thing is how anti-universalist it is. They're actually doing the job for the monocultural right-wing types who want to expunge all foreign cultures from the west by forcing whites to only express themselves via the dominant culture of wherever they happen to live.
This is exactly why people call them regressives, they just revivify old ways of thinking that we've been trying to do away with for decades. Modern so-called "anti-racism" is another example in the way it opposes racism by thinking about anything and everything racially.
This is exactly why people call them regressives, they just revivify old ways of thinking that we've been trying to do away with for decades. Modern so-called "anti-racism" is another example in the way it opposes racism by thinking about anything and everything racially.
HamburgerBoy
Active Member
- Sep 16, 2007
- 15,042
- 4,723
- 113
Related to the Hennessy tickets thing I mentioned earlier:
https://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/...on-Locked-Hair-Products-Racism-471317424.html
https://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/...on-Locked-Hair-Products-Racism-471317424.html
Einherjar86
Active Member
Even admitting this point, the problem is that permitting whites to dress up as Native Americans or whatnot doesn't let them somehow circumvent the expression of dominant culture. Ethnic costumes are never (okay, rarely--extremely rarely) historically accurate renderings of ethnic garb or traditions. They're reductive impressions drawn from earlier Western representations. For example, Native American costumes are based on the costumes in old Western films and political cartoons, which are themselves championing the practice of westward expansion and colonial displacement. They're images that we don't associate with actual Native practices or appearances, but with the popular images we've been greeted with on the silver screen, very few of which are culturally redeemable.
So when white people wear such costumes, they're not circumventing any association they might have with cultural dominance; they're reinforcing said dominance by donning the paraphernalia that have also contributed to that dominance.
It's been well-researched that part of occupation, as it's happened historically, is the reduction of subaltern peoples to images: of fear, of mockery, of pity, even of lust (hence all the scantily clad women dressed as Native Americans). When this happens, such images circulate among the colonial civilization as representations of the people they've displaced. This circulation gradually gives way to automatic impressions of said subaltern peoples which, lo and behold, turn into costumes. It's all about how this:
turns into this:
CiG
Coming of Age in the Milky Way
Native American costumes are one of the worst examples though, not all claims of "cultural appropriation" are of things so cartoonish and so blatantly a misrepresentation of the people who belong to the culture apparently being appropriated.
Similar threads
