rms
Active Member
if in a deploying/active unit yeah, but i think that's quite different than what you original posed
If Mort Divine ruled the world
- Thread starter Zephyrus
- Start date
CiG
Room with a View
Dak
mentat
Einherjar86
Active Member
Urban centers in the U.S. tend to be healthier than rural areas; and most people in cities tend to work office jobs.
This doesn't mean people working construction or physical jobs are fat, which is a ridiculous assumption. Physical labor is its own exercise; but those jobs also tend to demand physical exertion that isn't designed for body health. Additionally, because people in manual labor are working physically all day, they tend not to spend their mornings or evenings exercising.
Urban office workers tend to spend more time walking to work and training their bodies.
This doesn't mean people working construction or physical jobs are fat, which is a ridiculous assumption. Physical labor is its own exercise; but those jobs also tend to demand physical exertion that isn't designed for body health. Additionally, because people in manual labor are working physically all day, they tend not to spend their mornings or evenings exercising.
Urban office workers tend to spend more time walking to work and training their bodies.
CiG
Room with a View
rms
Active Member
this # is so minuscule yet you act like it's statistically significant. man this is a weird conversation for you
The Ozzman
Melted by feels
I think it's more that they don't have to own a car in the city because of proximity or they choose not to own one because parking is expensive. It isn't because of some strange desire to train their bodies. If I lived in a city and worked within the city, I would also walk to work because of the convenience factor regardless of being in shape or not.
Einherjar86
Active Member
Yes, there are. There are also studies showing that manual labor isn't very healthy either--not being active, which is certainly healthy, but plenty of manual labor jobs are also not very ergonomic.
It's not minuscule. According to the dept. of labor stats, the highest percentage of American jobs are professional/business and retail, many (if not most) of which are in urban or greater metropolitan areas. Now, this doesn't mean they outnumber the rest, but that's not "minuscule."
You often say things like this--"this is a weird conversation for you." This a rhetorical fallacy that combines elements of red herring and ad hominem: you're shifting focus from the argument to the fact that I'm focusing on it. But you're having the conversation too--so why isn't it weird for you?
You just don't like my argument, and you're collapsing that with presumptions about my character.
That is why many people walk, yes--but people in urban centers still tend to be healthier in general, particular when it comes to diet and exercise.
rms
Active Member
The Ozzman
Melted by feels
Einherjar86
Active Member
I think about this a lot. My time is so consumed with finishing my dissertation that I barely have a chance to check out new bands. It's kind of depressing.
The new Keldian album is bitchin though, although I don't think many people here really like them...
rms
Active Member
dude, healthy and ergonomic are not synonymous. this is why it's a weird conversation for you.
ok, you're not even following your own progression of thought here.
original claim : Urban office workers tend to spend more time walking to work and training their bodies.
me : this assertion that urban office workers are biking and walking to work for exercise is ridiculous in that the amount of people who actually do this is minuscule.
rebuttal: not addressing this at all because you already assume your assumption to the rational urban worker is correct when I have been arguing it is not right.
if people in the cities are so exercise conscious, why is urban development needed for LA with a fucking underground highway system or just standard subway/trolley development in any city? this is just not the norm even though you think it is. Because, yet again, those who live in cities tend to be smart/rational and think about all their actions and what they mean. You can't act like your own anecdotal life perspective isn't in question here when a majority of your claims are based on nothing but that.
and you can't start this "you don't like my argument" horseshit after you ignored several points now
Einherjar86
Active Member
I don't mean to be a dick, but your prose/responses are too ambiguous for you to complain about my comments.
Your response was directed at a comment from me that addressed walking to work and exercising. You proceeded to call that number "minuscule." I was referring to the population of urban workers because, generally speaking, urban centers tend to be healthier, i.e. people tend to walk to work more often and tend to exercise more. You're assuming that I'm conflating the two, but I'm saying they're separate activities.
If you want me to respond effectively to what you say, then you need to actually say what you mean.
CiG
Room with a View
Walking to work doesn't necessarily overlap with eating and drinking healthily, I'm sure I'm stating the obvious here.
Einherjar86
Active Member
Agreed, and I am generalizing. But it's true that people in major cities tend to be healthier--whether it's walking more, exercising more, eating healthier, or a combo, I'm not claiming to know one way or another.
It's also the case that the majority of urban and metropolitan jobs are in business, finance, etc.
Clearly this is a vague and highly general argument, and I'm not taking the time to go find stats on all this because I'm drawing on previous knowledge from various sources about the increase in urban jobs and the health of urban residents. I'm really sorry guys, but I just don't have time to go and find all the stats and numbers. I know you guys like that, so I understand if you won't trust the claims due to lack of statistical evidence. Pointing out that I'm not providing these won't change my mind, since I recall what I've read in the past (many of these sources go back years, which is why I'm not jumping up to go find them).
I really don't intend this to be insulting or stand-offish, but I kind of figure that if anyone cares to investigate a particular comment that is said on this forum, then he or she will go do some research of their own. That's how I approach this entire platform. We all say controversial things, but when one of you does so I usually go and do a Google search of my own.
It's also the case that the majority of urban and metropolitan jobs are in business, finance, etc.
Clearly this is a vague and highly general argument, and I'm not taking the time to go find stats on all this because I'm drawing on previous knowledge from various sources about the increase in urban jobs and the health of urban residents. I'm really sorry guys, but I just don't have time to go and find all the stats and numbers. I know you guys like that, so I understand if you won't trust the claims due to lack of statistical evidence. Pointing out that I'm not providing these won't change my mind, since I recall what I've read in the past (many of these sources go back years, which is why I'm not jumping up to go find them).
I really don't intend this to be insulting or stand-offish, but I kind of figure that if anyone cares to investigate a particular comment that is said on this forum, then he or she will go do some research of their own. That's how I approach this entire platform. We all say controversial things, but when one of you does so I usually go and do a Google search of my own.
Last edited:
rms
Active Member
moving on out of frustration:
Here is Coates' reply to a student asking about the use of the word "my pals" by non-blacks(maybe just whites)
I think his answer is whack. Desire & White people must own everything. blegh
Here is Coates' reply to a student asking about the use of the word "my pals" by non-blacks(maybe just whites)
I think his answer is whack. Desire & White people must own everything. blegh
rms
Active Member
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/09/arts/television/louis-ck-sexual-misconduct.html
Louis CK is a chronic masturbator, or at least was (15-12 year old allegations)
Louis CK is a chronic masturbator, or at least was (15-12 year old allegations)
no country for old wainds
Active Member
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,824
- 9,684
- 113
i've posted about this in two separate threads ya dork. but yeah this has been rumoured for at least two years and everyone has kind of known about it without being able to say too much. i was actually expecting this article to be worse, all things considered, but it's just more or less what we already knew - only more of it.
rms
Active Member
no country for old wainds
Active Member
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,824
- 9,684
- 113
Similar threads
