Purely stirring the waters, because typically I find merit in things in general but have found a total lack of everything interesting in one particular classic...
lord of the rings trilogy
Barf.
Have to come out of the closet on this one... my nerd credibility is beyond reproach, and I still cannot get anything out of the entire thing at all. Especially for someone not into 'fantasy'... it's quite troubling when everyone's idea of a 'fantasy' is basically 'Middle ages technology, but there's magic so it's totally awesome', and that the genre is largely predicated on the idea that that's largely the extent of imagining the unreal, and to nominate the thing that is largely responsible for defining the fantasy cliche is just begging to make another person who will be forever free from the horrible addiction of books.
"Whee, we're in a world that's largely based on the time period where diarrhea is the most fatal thing that people can almost spell, but clearly what we have to do is invent a super-duper-evil megabastard with malignant tendencies that actually could have been a lot worse with a little more creativity than 'basically just make another lord of our faultily-planned hierarchy that's evil because it enjoys eating cute things slightly more than the last guy and has a scary name and magic and stuff!"
It is nothing short of disappointing that so many ideas of 'escapism' boil down to 'the same existence that we happily grew out of, but with a dim child's play as a deus ex machina' and thoroughly neglect 'well, if space wasn't three dimensional we wouldn't even be able to tie our shoes, let's run with the consequences of that *actual departure from both the common and the common-plus-things-slightly-uncommon-but-useful-only-for-advancing-plots-and-never-examined-in-a-light-that-would-truly-expose-interesting-consequences-to-alterations-in-our-view-of-reality-that-are-basically-just-how-people-thought-stuff-worked-before-they-knew-anything*'.
Sure, there's a lot of deviation from the norm involved in 'here are a bunch of people, except they're not like real people because these guys are shorter, these are also shorter and somewhat thinner, these guys are also shorter but in a different way and also some stuff, and this guy isn't shorter at all but he has a stick and also some spells and things', but I think we can do better if we're going to convince anyone that fiction truly escapes the common in order to describe things beyond our imagination. If someone's turned off by 'fantasy', LOTR is quite likely why - if not because he already read it then because his other dives into 'fantasy' were so plagued by such total lack of the actually fantastic that the whole idea has turned uninteresting.
Yeah, yeah... 'He invented a new type of world!' 'He invented a new language just to add authenticity and enable immersion!' 'Blah-dee-doo-dee-dah!' 'I still eat Fruit Roll-Ups!' Shut up. Those are *homework exercises*, not fundamental alterations to our perceptions of things in general. If you want fiction, go *completely* past that. Doctor Who has more invention, more truly bizarre, more pure detachment from the ordinary than any of that... and it stars, for the most part, a British guy surrounded by British people in costumes made in the UK doing stereotypical things in a stereotypical manner and escaping through what is a magical blue box, full stop, end of discussion... *on TV*. If your idea of 'fantasizing' involves 'I'll be the one lucky guy in a society predicated on 'we're going to die before half of today's college students know what they want to do with their lives, so how about some Renaissance Festival play and an occasional I'm-Your-God-Now bunch of handwaving' and not 'I'm going to bend every possible rule of reality because I can', then your imagination is dead and you're going to die alone with a lot of cats.
Historical and cultural significance aside - and while we're at that we're probably not turning anyone on to literary enjoyment with the Magna goddamn Carta, so that has limited relevance here - Lord of the Rings has quite limited value to a reader who explicitly stated that he was not into fantasy *as the first thing that he said about his tastes*.
Jef