Is there a song more emotional and beautiful then 'One last goodbye' ?

Lost Control, Feel, Regret, Inner Silence, Judgement, A Fine Day To Exit, Far Away, Angelica... These are songs close to what you discribed I reckon... Can't really see why One Last Goodbye stands above 'em. They're all great in my opinion!
 
many songs of Anathema are that emotional & beautiful (i.e "Emotional Winter" from that album)
 
I think Dunc hasn't listened to Judgement that much or am I wrong? I personally love this song, but it's 'only' one great song among others. I think I listened to it way too many times during last year so now I kinda try to keep a little distance to it...
 
there are many gentile songs like one last goodbye.
check out nick cave's henry lee and loom of the land,and madrugada-electric.

about judgement,the title track is my fav,great song!although it has such a pink floydish end,which i cant help not noticing off.