Katatonia vs. Anathema
- Thread starter JayKeeley
- Start date
Papa Josh
Minister of Propaganda
To BrownEyeoftheStorm: I respect your right to your opinion, but you need to wipe your ass after that last bout of bullshit.
Judgement is excellent, the track One Last Goodbye one of the most beautiful songs ever written.
This thread is a difficult choice. On one hand I love Katatonia's guitar tones, on the other I like Vincent's voice better than Jonas'... and Anathema's "Pentecost III" is one of the most landmark doom albums ever. I pull out all of my Anathema's cds much more than all of my Katatonia cds, so Anathema it is.
Judgement is excellent, the track One Last Goodbye one of the most beautiful songs ever written.
This thread is a difficult choice. On one hand I love Katatonia's guitar tones, on the other I like Vincent's voice better than Jonas'... and Anathema's "Pentecost III" is one of the most landmark doom albums ever. I pull out all of my Anathema's cds much more than all of my Katatonia cds, so Anathema it is.
IOfTheStorm
Gogol Bordello
Yea sorry, shit came brown because i was talking about "Judgement". In "One Last Goodbye" Vincent sings like his parents did not buy him the "wanted for all eternity" lolipop (or icecream). The whole album is the definition of non-inspiration... musical "ideas" that were used 43534534 times in the past, the lyrics are ridiculus, and all the REALLY BEAUTIFUL music of "Eternity" (for example), was just a dream for the fans who have ears, and a nightmare for the girls screaming with wet pants on their hands "VINCENT LICK MY PIERCED TIT"
Will Bozarth
Everlasting Godstopper
Will Bozarth
Everlasting Godstopper
the reason why One Last Goodbye sounds like he was talking to his parents is because he was singing about his mom that fucking DIED. show some goddamn respect. the whole cd is dedicated to her
IOfTheStorm
Gogol Bordello
yea, i know about that stuff, but my comment about the song wasnt about that .. to me it sounds like a "mourning for the lost lolipop i had on my first day in circus"
Will Bozarth
Everlasting Godstopper
Papa Josh
Minister of Propaganda
Jeez, you are a dipshit...IOfTheStorm said:
"I know about that stuff..."
So, in regards to this debate, how is ripping off Cure riffs and emoting Robert Smith and Jeff Buckley make Katatonia more inspirational and original?
IOfTheStorm
Gogol Bordello
Ok so "I know about that stuff" (that meant that i know to who the cavanagh brothers dedicated the album, and to who they are talking in one last goodbye) makes me a dipshit .Papa Josh said:
Learn not to make personal attacks to the person who talks shit about the ALBUMS and not the PEOPLE who like the ALBUM, alright? well done
ProgMetalFan
In the attic
Both bands are brilliant yet deeply flawed. I think both have extremely uneven discographies and I hate the most recent offerings by both. I'll give Anathema the nod. "Judgement" is simply an incredible work.
Drynwhyl
infp
Katatonia
won't explain why, there's no need, have done it many times before.
"a relief for a disclocated mind
shelter for thoughts
asylum for my soul ..."
won't explain why, there's no need, have done it many times before.
"a relief for a disclocated mind
shelter for thoughts
asylum for my soul ..."
Erik
New Metal Member
"Judgement" rules (and sadly, it was the last Anathema album to rule.) Of the pre-"A Fine Day to Exit" albums, "Eternity" is my least favourite by far.
Erik
New Metal Member
