posted at
http://www.darksoul7.com
ABIGAIL WILLIAMS
LEGEND (EP)
Candlelight Records
10/03/06
Review By: Turtlspinr
Line Up:
Ken Sorceron - Vocals
Bjorn Dannov - Guitar
Kyle Dickinson - Bass
Ashley "Ellyllon" Jurgemeyer - Keyboards
Zach Gibson - Drums
Track Listing:
01. From A Buried Heart
02. Like Carrion Birds
03. Conqueror Wyrm
04. Watchtower
05. Procession Of The Aeons
Coming from Arizona, Abigail Williams started as collaboration between three-fifths of Vehemence (Bjorn Dannov, Andy Schroeder, and Mark Kozuback), put together with Ken Rothschild aka Ken Sorceron (guitars), Ashley Jurgemeyer, aka Ellyllon (keys), and Connor Woods (vocals). January 2006 saw Woods, Schroeder, Kozuback, and Dannov exit, with Dannov returning a few months later. The group was then rounded out by Zach Gibson (Black Dahlia Murder/drums), Kyle Dickinson (bass), Mike Wilson (touring guitars), with Rothschild switching to vocals and studio guitar. However, donât get too attached to any one lineup, as itâll probably be different by the time you read this anyway.
With the membership thing out of the way, letâs get down to the rumors. Iâm sure everyone has heard that this is a hardcore band, or that there are rampant breakdowns, that this isnât real metal, that the members look like hardcore kids, blah blah blah. Iâm sure that everyone has heard that this sounds like a mix between Dusk And Her Embrace-era Cradle of Filth and Vehemence. Iâm sure that everyone had heard that there are clean vocals, and that the keyboards have ruined the record.
Yea, Iâve heard all that too, but Iâve actually listened to the record, and seen Abigail Williams live, so hereâs the deal. Yep, it sounds like Vehemence (Dannov after all wrote 80% of the Vehemence material), yep there are keyboards, and no they donât ruin anything. Theyâre used in the same way Bleeding Through, Scar Symmetry and Soilwork all used keyboards, to add layers.. Yep some members have short hair, and yep, thereâs clean singing. And about that whole ânot metalâ thing. Well, yea, thatâs bullshit, because this is most certainly metal. What specific genre it fits in, Iâm not sure, but itâs definitely not hardcore.
Track 1, âFrom A Buried Heartâ starts off, honestly, in a not too promising way. Sounds like bad Polish black metal (think Hermh). However, that changed quickly, diving into an At The Gates type feeling, followed by a chorus with some clean singing. Letâs address this immediately. Sometimes, clean singing works. Sometimes it doesnât. This is a case where I feel it doesnât. It really seems to suck out the energy and intensity of the song. However, it does seem to create a better dynamic, and make the sections of blasting all that more brutal. Anyway, this song features some tasty soloing, snappy double bass, and great guitar work, and a nice piano outro. I must say though, that Iâm not crazy about the vocal work in this song, as the vocals during the verses seem to be poorly though out, and just seem to be there, as opposed to fitting well. However, the overall song is good, but not great.
Track 2, âLike Carrion Birdsâ, is a fucking monster. Best song on the record. I heard this song about a year ago when the original demo came out, and it was a monster then, if a little long. The fat has been trimmed, and this song will rip your head clean from your shoulders. 3 minutes, 43 seconds of awesomeness. Opens with crushing guitars, punishing double bass, and keys sprinkled over the whole thing, creating something both brutal and beautiful. This is how keys should be used in metal. Also, this is how repetition should be used as well. The opening section is used over and over again, as a chorus would be, which works well, as this song is lacking a real chorus. After the second verse comes the first solo, which is killer, but short. Itâs followed by what Iâm calling a post-solo pre-solo, and then another solo, which is longer, and equally as cool. That solo is followed by what Iâm sure people will scream is a breakdown, but really, itâs not. Itâs just a little break leading into more blasting and full on metal glory, before going right back into the verse. The ending is again what some people may call a breakdown, but I donât see it as such. Yes, the guitars are playing a staccato pattern, but the drums and keys keep things moving right along. Again, best song on the record.
Track 3, âConqueror Wyrmâ, is very different from everything else on the record. It reminds me of From The Depths. If anyone else remembers them, theyâll get the reference, and understand what Iâm trying to say. Itâs a little slower, with the keys (used as violins) taking much more of a dominant role. This song is quite dynamic, ranging from the At The Gates type polka beat to a slower, almost gothic type feeling, with the keys really standing out. There is some clean singing on this song, right around the halfway point, and I like how itâs used. From this point on, the song takes a much different feeling, with the keys REALLY coming to the front, again, really seeming to take a cue from From The Depths. This influence continues until the end of the song. Truth be told, the last half of the song is far superior to the first half. Reminds me a lot of From The Depths and newer Eternal Tears Of Sorrow.
Track 4, âWatchtowerâ, is my least favorite on the record. Heavy influence from late 90s drum machine based black metal, which isnât a bad thing, but it just doesnât fit in with the other songs. The sound quality is different, it sounds like a drum machine may have actually be used, the guitars have a different tone than anywhere else, the vocals are way more out in front than on the other songsâ¦this song just doesnât seem to fit the record at all. However, I will say that the solo is absolutely blistering. Aside from that, Iâm not terribly impressed with this song.
Track 5, âProcession Of The Aeonsâ, however, is another killer song. This song really letâs all members stretch their legs, with each of them absolutely going off. The drums are phenomenal, with some of the tightest gravity blasts Iâve ever heard, the guitars are raging, and the piano work is amazing, even if it is being covered by all the other instruments. The vocals are a little lower in the mix on this song, which is a good thing, so that you can hear the music a bit better. Iâm having a hard time describing this song in a step by step manner, as it bounces around a lot. Elements of black metal, hardcore, grind, and death are all crammed together in an almost scattershot way, though still making a coherent song. Imagine elements Necrophagist, Eternal Tears Of Sorrow, At The Gates, Dark Funeral and Vehemence all crammed together. At the same time. Now youâve got it. Try as I might, I canât make a better description than that.
This is, in short, an excellent record. Itâs not perfect, but itâs definitely got some very good points. âLike Carrion Birdsâ and âProcession Of The Aeonsâ are about as good as metal will get. âFrom A Carrion Heartâ and âConqueror Wyrmâ have some very strong points, but need to be focused a little more. Even âWatchtowerâ, while being by far my least favorite song on this record, has some very strong points.
Let me break them down for you:
--killer guitar work. Dannov and Rothschild can both shred.
--amazing drumming. Zach Gibson is a monster.
-- Ashley Jurgemeyerâs keyboard work is seriously bad ass. (anyone else have a degree in music composition from Arizona State?). Unfortunately, her work serves more as a backup, or another layer in the song a lot of the time, rather than standing out. But, make the effort to really listen, and youâll hear that this girl can flat out play.
--venomous vocals. I didnât mention them a lot, because like the keyboards, sometimes they tend to be relegated to a support role, rather than a point of focus.
With a little more focus, Abigail Williams could be one of the best metal bands of all time, and no, I donât think thatâs an overstatement, because theyâve certainly got the talent to do it. However, their success depends largely on the metal community dropping their preconceived notions of what this band is, and what this band sounds like, and focusing on the fact that these guys are turning out some seriously good brutal and simultaneously melodic metal.