All cabs are fully capable of giving you a decent recorded tone - period. No fucking discussion. If you can't get a good sound out of it, then it is YOU.
But for live usage, where you need to fill a room... that's a different story.
We used a 1960B with a Laney VH100R on the TNBD album; it fucking slays.
I agree for the most part, unless it's some cheap "beginner halfstack" cab. Even then, I've gotten shockingly decent results from a Line 6 Spider III half stack. It's just lame to see all these dudes limiting themselves to V30's because everyone says they're the best.
, but I got the 1960B!