Might as well get it out of the way now...

[Russell]

Whats ur favourite Anathema album?

 

[Garm]

Silent enigma!! Emotions, emotions atop of emotions, and as a sphere within you find the peace of mind that no other material or spiritual muster.

 

[pince]

A Fine Day To Exit

 

[Russell]

I am now gonna call myself a bastard cos this is fucking hard!

 

[my dying groom]

Alternative 4

 

[Judge gsz]

not because it's the new one, but because it's the best one :

A Fine Day To Exit


Judge

 

[kim larsen]

alt 4. og judgment (boht are amazing)

 

[Russell]

In my carefully considered opinion, I'm going for alterntive four AND TSE I never said there had 2 b 1

 

[Mark]

Judgement = Perfection

 

[Demonspell]

I voted for Eternity in the poll, but it really depends on what kind of mood I'm in. That saying, I can easily listen to TSE and Exit back to back...

 

[_Transparent_]

alternative 4, although i don't like the metalica wannabe parts of anathema (crawls up and bows down, awaiting a severe beating)

 

[Lord S]

I still LOVE Serenades!

 

[S4R]

I am so happy this forum is finally here. My favorite Anathemas album, Eternity.

 

[Gdc]

The Silent Enigma and on second place Alternative 4!

 

[Melancholia]

Eternity and on second place The silent enigma

 

[Russell]

Originally posted by Soul4Raziel
I am so happy this forum is finally here

Heh, me 2

 

[D Mullholand]

Ok, I'll be the pedantic pedantus, so you'll get a whole list from me (I haven't included Exit, since I've heard it only twice) :

1. Judgement
2. Eternity
3. Alternative 4
...
4. The Silent Enigma
...
...
...
5. Crestfallen
6. Pentecost III
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
7. That other album (starts with S)

D Mullholand, the Messiaen of Anti-Serenadaism

 

[Nico16]

Alternative 4 ...I love it, especially "lost control"!!

It's a shame that Duncan left after Alt. 4, he wrote some of their best songs and lyrics ...would be cool if he came back to the band...

 

[benny]

Judgement then possibly Serenades.

 

[Triste]

Narrowing it down to 3 (is that ok?)

Serenades
The Silent Enigma
Pentacost III (the lyrics are so melodramatic....)