Serge... said:
You're all wrong about lessons. Getting lessons can be very helpful if you have the right teacher. Having guidance from an experienced player is the best possible way of improving. I mean, nowadays with the internet, it's possible to get really good without lessons, but I see a lot of self taught players who can't coordinate their hands and don't know what they're doing. Even worse, they don't know that what they're doing is wrong. Getting lessons won't make you into a clone, it'll just speed up your process of mastering basic techniques. And since everyone's using famous people as examples, Satch taught Vai.
Oh and another thing, having a teacher will help you learn theory, and a player that knows theory is a better player period. Ask anyone that knows theory and they'll say it helps them immensly while teh only people that argue don't know any.
I agree with the lessons thing.
I never said they sucked, i jsut said i chose not to have them.
I can coordinate myself fine and i not as much practise strictly but i learned 90% of the shit i know, Techniques and stuff from learning other songs.
The First solo i learned was PAntera-Cowboys from Hell. BEfore that solo i couldn't pinch, stretch, alt pick fast or anything and so i worked on those becuase i needed them... now i do that song flawlessly (This was 3 years ago i learned it).
Lessons dont always equate to a better player, Look agt players like Wes Montgomery, they know fuck all theory, they play by ear and they play their asses off and rock.
I do however disagree with Lessons/theory =better player.
I know quite a lot of theory ( i have studied music for the past 3 years at the highest level my school offers and do a lot of shit at home too) but see, writing riffs that sound good is what counts not keeping it within a scale.
I have written many Atonal riffs that sound badass and can fit over chord progressions easily that are without ANY key Center(hence Atonal) and are not wiothin any scale.
If it sounds musical, its music regardless of all the technicalities.
Also, remember, music was made before modes were discovered....
Theory is not the Be all and End all of insturmental greatness, it jsut helps.