Let's make me a good bassist... tips?

[ESA1996]

I need insight on approaching rhythm guitar sections in song writing. Do you guys do inversions of the same chord elements or what? Play stuff within a major 2nd or such interval or something to create dissonance (in genres like black metal)? Some nice tips would be appreciated.

Major 7th, minor 2nd, and a diminished 5th are the most dissonant intervals you can have. AFAIK even black metal doesn't use them a whole lot though as it just results in a messy sound. Lots of minor chords and loads of distortion are worth a try. E minor > C minor certainly sounds gloomy. Harmonic minor is also better for black metal than natural I think. The 5th and 4th modes of the harmonic minor are also great (The 5th is called Phygrian Dominant, no idea what the 4th is called if it even has a proper name).

 

[ESA1996]

Would love to have such an attic too indeed. Always loved houses that have one.
This is otherwise not a really great blackmetal. I think you give her a pass because she's a nice looking girl ^^ The "riffs" and "chords" are too predictable for it to be actually enjoyable. I don't want blck metal to become progressive, but it's always nice with that element of surprise. Don't know if you know about them yet, but if not, give the band Windir a shot. I think they are as good as black metal will ever get.

Try Caladan Brood. Not exactly what one expects from black metal I think but it's the one black metal band I actively listen to.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

I'm about to give you guys something back for the help... I think tomorrow when I have coffee.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

So...

I've done lots of thinking on how to approach designing a song or album, in terms of musical psychology. Instead of just venting out what comes naturally (or playing random shit and salvaging the cherries) I wanted to come up with some system. Because going full spontaneous just tends to end up with describing your current mood in life. Good maybe if you're angry and depressed and you want to create angry and depressed metal. But it tends to spawn mishmash songs where ideas don't really unite in best way. I realized this when I made my first few songs. They were too similar even tho they had different sections obviously. I think you're not supposed to have every element in one song.

First I figured I need to decide the mood and style of the album itself. Let's say melancholic and medium-fast. This sets rough limits which serve as guidelines and prevent getting lost out of style. Some things can change from song to song, section to section, but for the album composing and recording there's standard sounds. Then I pondered a pattern what makes an album have certain mood, such as melancholy. The guitar tone is most important as it will be set in stone. I formed a rough pattern of moods and guitar tones and marked X where I thought a certain tone and atmosphere fit together.

MOODS: ______Haunting – Melancholy – Malevolence – Anger – Mystery – Sorrow – Doom
TONES: Bright _____x_________x____________________________x_______ x ______x
_______Biting ________________x___________x_________x_____________________x
_______Crisp ________________x___________x________________x_______x______
_______Crunch __________________________x_________x______________________x
_______Dark _______x________x___________x_________x_______x_______x______x
_______Open _____________________________________________x_______x______x
_______Punchy ____________________________________x______________x______x
_______Smooth ____x_________x____________________________x________x______x
_______Warm _____x_________x_____________________x______________x_______x
_______Muddy ____x_________x______________________x_______x______________x
_______Hollow _____x_______________________________x______x________x______

I then chose to have a certain tone that fits the idea of mood I want. The purpose of all this is to find a logical path to steer when selecting elements for a song you want to create, ensuring you can have different songs on the album instead of every song being clone. Some elements don't go together, and even tho this should be intuitive for an artist, you sometimes aren't sure what mood you're chasing in your song.

Then I started thinking how to approach designing a song. I made similar diagram for feelings of melody when it comes to speed.

EMOTION: ________ Haunting – Melancholy – Malevolence – Anger – Mystery – Sorrow – Doom
SPEED:
_______Very slow ______x_____________________________________________________x
_______Slow __________x_________x____________________x_______x_______x______x
_______Medium _____________________________x________________x_______________x
_______Fast __________x_________x___________x_________x______x________x_______
_______Very fast _________________x__________x__________x______________x_______

You could make such diagrams with many things. Such as: which atmospheres can co-exist? But there is a limit to making etheric art to a mathematical formula.

Then I made a diagram of drum speed emotion when it comes to emotion created by drums. With drums the emotions created are different. I believe drumming is primitively linked to human heartbeat in conjunction with emotion. (I neglected emotions that aren't black metal, such as euphory.)

EMOTION: ___________Sad_______Depressed____Angry____Fearful______Vicious
SPEED:
_______Very slow ______x_____________x___________________x____________
_______Slow __________x_____________x_________x____________________x
_______Medium _______x_______________________x_____________________x
_______Fast __________x_______________________x_________x___________x
_______Very fast ______x________________________x_________x__________x

I tried thinking the correct order in which to decide on these things, because each decision sets boundaries.

1) Choose a desired atmosphere and a desired feeling/emotion for it. For example sad & mysterious, or sad & doomy (you can have different aspects for certain mood.)
2) Choose a fitting 'drum speed.'
3) Choose a fitting 'guitar speed.'
4) If you have a twist of emotions in a song, decide if you want different instruments to create different emotions, or the same ones. Such as 'sad drums' and 'doomy guitars', or 'doomy drums' and 'sad guitars.' I have my theory how rhythm guitar, bass and synths operate in psychology, but I'll leave that out here, it gets embarrassingly deep. But that is when you really create layers of dimension to a song. A song is a story told in energy waves: what happens, in what kind of place, how it makes you feel physically, how it makes you feel mentally, and how it changes your fate. With five instruments you can tell that a person get lost in a cold forest and is hurting and is worried and can no longer take life for given.

These together create the colour and character of a song. With lyrics you can elaborate on the theme. I like to think of the task of true creativity as making two feelings meet in a song. This creates a magical depth.

These formulas purposefully neglect "style of playing" and "composion ideas." They just serve a foundation, helping to dictate song ideas and sections of a song (varying speeds and moods.) Creativity of selecting notes is up to the artist. This way we don't end up with a million useless songs with I-IV-V chord progressions...

 

[Inceptionist]

So...

I've done lots of thinking on how to approach designing a song or album, in terms of musical psychology. Instead of just venting out what comes naturally (or playing random shit and salvaging the cherries) I wanted to come up with some system. Because going full spontaneous just tends to end up with describing your current mood in life. Good maybe if you're angry and depressed and you want to create angry and depressed metal. But it tends to spawn mishmash songs where ideas don't really unite in best way. I realized this when I made my first few songs. They were too similar even tho they had different sections obviously. I think you're not supposed to have every element in one song.

First I figured I need to decide the mood and style of the album itself. Let's say melancholic and medium-fast. This sets rough limits which serve as guidelines and prevent getting lost out of style. Some things can change from song to song, section to section, but for the album composing and recording there's standard sounds. Then I pondered a pattern what makes an album have certain mood, such as melancholy. The guitar tone is most important as it will be set in stone. I formed a rough pattern of moods and guitar tones and marked X where I thought a certain tone and atmosphere fit together.

MOODS: ______Haunting – Melancholy – Malevolence – Anger – Mystery – Sorrow – Doom
TONES: Bright _____x_________x____________________________x_______ x ______x
_______Biting ________________x___________x_________x_____________________x
_______Crisp ________________x___________x________________x_______x______
_______Crunch __________________________x_________x______________________x
_______Dark _______x________x___________x_________x_______x_______x______x
_______Open _____________________________________________x_______x______x
_______Punchy ____________________________________x______________x______x
_______Smooth ____x_________x____________________________x________x______x
_______Warm _____x_________x_____________________x______________x_______x
_______Muddy ____x_________x______________________x_______x______________x
_______Hollow _____x_______________________________x______x________x______

I then chose to have a certain tone that fits the idea of mood I want. The purpose of all this is to find a logical path to steer when selecting elements for a song you want to create, ensuring you can have different songs on the album instead of every song being clone. Some elements don't go together, and even tho this should be intuitive for an artist, you sometimes aren't sure what mood you're chasing in your song.

Then I started thinking how to approach designing a song. I made similar diagram for feelings of melody when it comes to speed.

EMOTION: ________ Haunting – Melancholy – Malevolence – Anger – Mystery – Sorrow – Doom
SPEED:
_______Very slow ______x_____________________________________________________x
_______Slow __________x_________x____________________x_______x_______x______x
_______Medium _____________________________x________________x_______________x
_______Fast __________x_________x___________x_________x______x________x_______
_______Very fast _________________x__________x__________x______________x_______

You could make such diagrams with many things. Such as: which atmospheres can co-exist? But there is a limit to making etheric art to a mathematical formula.

Then I made a diagram of drum speed emotion when it comes to emotion created by drums. With drums the emotions created are different. I believe drumming is primitively linked to human heartbeat in conjunction with emotion. (I neglected emotions that aren't black metal, such as euphory.)

EMOTION: ___________Sad_______Depressed____Angry____Fearful______Vicious
SPEED:
_______Very slow ______x_____________x___________________x____________
_______Slow __________x_____________x_________x____________________x
_______Medium _______x_______________________x_____________________x
_______Fast __________x_______________________x_________x___________x
_______Very fast ______x________________________x_________x__________x

I tried thinking the correct order in which to decide on these things, because each decision sets boundaries.

1) Choose a desired atmosphere and a desired feeling/emotion for it. For example sad & mysterious, or sad & doomy (you can have different aspects for certain mood.)
2) Choose a fitting 'drum speed.'
3) Choose a fitting 'guitar speed.'
4) If you have a twist of emotions in a song, decide if you want different instruments to create different emotions, or the same ones. Such as 'sad drums' and 'doomy guitars', or 'doomy drums' and 'sad guitars.' I have my theory how rhythm guitar, bass and synths operate in psychology, but I'll leave that out here, it gets embarrassingly deep. But that is when you really create layers of dimension to a song. A song is a story told in energy waves: what happens, in what kind of place, how it makes you feel physically, how it makes you feel mentally, and how it changes your fate. With five instruments you can tell that a person get lost in a cold forest and is hurting and is worried and can no longer take life for given.

These together create the colour and character of a song. With lyrics you can elaborate on the theme. I like to think of the task of true creativity as making two feelings meet in a song. This creates a magical depth.

These formulas purposefully neglect "style of playing" and "composion ideas." They just serve a foundation, helping to dictate song ideas and sections of a song (varying speeds and moods.) Creativity of selecting notes is up to the artist. This way we don't end up with a million useless songs with I-IV-V chord progressions...

The issue you’re going to run into is that following a “structure” when composing will tend to sound very forced. Even though it’s just a guideline, you’ll end up sunconsciously thinking “and now I need a melancholic riff, which should consist of this bass tone, at this speed, with drums playing at this speed”. Everyone does it at first. Like, once you learn to play in, say, the key of E minor, and know that scale really well, you will almost always fall back to playing in that scale and in that scale only. While guidelines can be helpful, just like knowing what sound a certain scale portrays, they’re only tools to keep in the back of your head, don’t let them be a creative crutch like most people. The moment you start sitting there thinking “I want to write something that sounds like X” you’re guaranteed to write something unoriginal, because in your head you already know what you’ve been taught sounds like “X”. Don’t try to convey a certain mood in your writing. Write something that you like that comes out naturally, whatever mood it creates is the mood it creates, try not to force it or fall back on guidelines.

In my first ever music theory course like a decade ago the professor said something I still remember: “You’re not going to learn the secret to writing good music here. Trust me, there is no secret, but everyone thinks there is. I’m going to give you the keys to seeing new colors. That’s what music theory is. If you were a painter and only knew two colors, you could only express yourself in those two colors. Music theory opens up a whole new world of colors for the painter to experiment with. It’s a world of new possibilities. So it’s your job to take these new colors and mix them into a completely original one.”

 

[(__Joonas__)]

Yeah, too strict planning is not good either. I think it's still a worthy thought process to go thru to try to formulate the style of art you're doing. With no guidelines it's easy to get lost, but when the route is planned beforehand with a red pencil, the trip can end up lacking a sense of adventurous creativity. I think in the end it's about having map and compass but not flatout planning everything beforehand. After all, music tends to contain colours that exceed our known colours, and atmosphere that cannot be described with one or even two words. But still, it's really interesting. Maybe start with a plan but don't worry if it goes somewhere else.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

When you do two guitars for a song, how do you record your other guitar to play the other guitar part over it and hear how they sound together? I mean what is the most handy device for this?

And about the orchestral hits, I'm not gonna use them, they only suit Bodom's type of music. I'm not gonna use keyboards at all, because they're like a shortcut to making music have "feeling" too easily and they bury the guitars. I just have some parts planned I'd need a keyboard for, but I'll make them with guitar somehow I guess...

 

[ESA1996]

When you do two guitars for a song, how do you record your other guitar to play the other guitar part over it and hear how they sound together? I mean what is the most handy device for this?

And about the orchestral hits, I'm not gonna use them, they only suit Bodom's type of music. I'm not gonna use keyboards at all, because they're like a shortcut to making music have "feeling" too easily and they bury the guitars. I just have some parts planned I'd need a keyboard for, but I'll make them with guitar somehow I guess...

What do you record with? I use Cubase, but Pro Tools, Logic Pro, Reaper and others are also very viable options. These allow you to play basically an unlimited amount of tracks at once (Limited only by the performance of your computer). Say I'm recording some kind of a riff. I record it once, put it on solo and listen it through with just the metronome at the back. If it sounds like it's in perfect time, I record it again, put the new recording on solo and then listen to the new recording with just the metronome at the back. If it again sounds good, I then listen to both guitars at the same time and if there are any timing problems, I try find out which recording is the cause of these and re-record. Same process for lead guitars.

I currently pan both rhythm and lead guitars 80L and 80R. Solos are in the center. If I have a harmony for the lead I'll pan those 80L and 80R, so that results in two rhythms, two leads and two harmonies, all panned 80L and 80R. If the rhythm guitars are playing slightly different stuff I don't record two guitars for both parts, I just leave them so that the left guitar plays something slightly different than the right one.

I'm surprised you're planning on leaving the keyboards out. Perhaps just mix them to be pretty quiet? They'll still add to the mix but won't take a lead position nor will they bury the guitars.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

I'm currently just composing the songs to Tux Guitar (playing ideas on guitar and from my mind first), I have no recording device or program or knowledge. So I need to look into that at some point... I don't even know yet if I'll record everything myself or with other guys... if it's by myself then the drums will likely not be real drums... cos there's nowhere to even access a real drumset.

Thing is if I only made a short keyboard piece per song, it would be silly to have a keyboardist when playing live... I know this kind of bands have the keyboards coming from a playback at live events, but I'd imagine that's difficult to arrange...?

 

[ESA1996]

Cubase at least has a half decent drum machine that comes with it (At least mine did, it's really old so I don't know what you get with it nowadays).

As for backing tracks, they're really common and I don't think they're that difficult to make work. You need a laptop and then just plug it into a speaker. Usually it's the drummer who then operates the laptop and hits play but, don't think anyone would mind if the bassist did it.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

I'm kind of having a musical challenge, not relying on keyboards for atmosphere, and not relying on notes below E for heaviness. At least it's a developing way to start off. Still not 100% sure that's the setting it will end up with.

 

[ESA1996]

I'm kind of having a musical challenge, not relying on keyboards for atmosphere, and not relying on notes below E for heaviness. At least it's a developing way to start off. Still not 100% sure that's the setting it will end up with.

You sound like me (Developing rules to go by and trying to make a formula for everything I've been trying to learn away from it for the past six or so years (While simultaneously making more such rules and formulas)).

 

[(__Joonas__)]

It's true. Seeing and making patterns is the definition of a wizard. Today I was creating one over a sports regime.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

I've made a massive leap in grasping the songwriting. You'll be floored when you hear this shit one day.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

Really can't decide whether to use keyboard or not... I only want it for some ghostly choirs sounds. Also there's the aspect of piano having the attacky, lush but short sound, which can't be emulated with guitar. I need to think if I can come up with choirs that fit this type of metal... Maybe I'm limiting myself unnecessarily with E and no keyboard?... But I tried different tunings again and I just like the tight sound of E, and I hate bulky strings on guitar... Of course D is great with its type of music, but even D seems too low for black metal. I was considering drop D, but it encourages using the low power chords so much that it steers away from black metal subconsciously. On E I just miss a couple lower power chords sometimes. I'm challenging myself to create heaviness with music rather than sound.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

Nearly finished with a new song (one of the seven I've been planning all along), and it's manifesting as I intended. Same as in my other creative hobby it's like I'm incubating certain ideas for a long time and eventually they sort of give birth to themselves. First there's an abstract idea that evolves to something more concrete until I sort of see how it's crafted. I like to have an idea in my mind before grabbing the instrument and talking with it.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

I now have five songs ready out of the seven (minus some arrangements). It's shaping up to be a hell of an album. Can't wait to let you hear it. It's got a strong theme and artwork also.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

I can now answer my own question of old about staying within scale or not.

It's challenging enough creativity-wise to make interesting music with all notes that exist, so limiting yourself to a certain scale is like voluntarily crippling yourself by tearing off your legs before war. I give special mention to the acoustic guitar guys who are overly concerned about theory and want to write songs in those mathematical formations they think is the only correct way to do it... wonder why they almost never write a good song... not to say they could if they forgot about theory, but are they really so invalid creativity-wise they voluntarily enslave themselves to those silly chord progression rules and being careful about not investigating anything interesting...

I stopped thinking about the scale completely and just think about intervals. Especially black metal uses dissonance deliberately, it just has to be done tastefully, just as the softening satisfaction of tension to release is used sparingly.

 

[(__Joonas__)]

My album is now done! I should have it put on youtube within a month or so. It's extremely atmospheric, shamanic black metal with gripping ideas in each of the seven songs. I learned some tricks along the way how to make interesting sections. Is it a good way to prove your album belongs to you copyright-wise by uploading it on youtube? I need to be sure of that. What else can I do?

I'll just check some fingerings and work some more on the lyrics and look for a drummer and singer and place to record.

 

[ESA1996]

My album is now done! I should have it put on youtube within a month or so. It's extremely atmospheric, shamanic black metal with gripping ideas in each of the seven songs. I learned some tricks along the way how to make interesting sections. Is it a good way to prove your album belongs to you copyright-wise by uploading it on youtube? I need to be sure of that. What else can I do?

I'll just check some fingerings and work some more on the lyrics and look for a drummer and singer and place to record.

I doubt you'll get it on YT within a month if you haven't recorded it yet, but I'm eager to hear it anyway when it's finished.

Any form of online media that you can prove to be yours should be fine for copyright. How many unsigned bands are there that don't upload their songs to YouTube etc? I certainly don't know any.

As for other places to upload the album, you can try Soundcloud or Bandcamp (This might end up making you little money even as Bandcamp is meant for selling music). If you want the album on Spotify you can do that (For free) through RouteNote.