ROYAL CARNAGE APRIL MADNESS: Round #6.68: IT NEVER ENDS OH MY FUCKING GOD

[Erik]

Vote on a BAND BASIS!

Agalloch vs. Metallica

OK this means that you have to consider whatever Load, Re-load and St. Anger has done to tarnish your opinion of Metallica. Again, 12 hours.

 

[J.]

Agalloch

 

[MFJ]

Agalloch.

 

[Lutz]

Agalloch

 

[Erik]

Agalloch

 

[Chromatose]

well this one is easier then


Agalloch

 

[Hell Mike]

Metallica

 

[J.]

so if this one is a tie, does it come down to The Mantle vs. St. Anger?

 

[Erik]

No, pay attention faghat. In MY tournament, album ties have always been resolved by band votes.

EDIT: Oh if THIS one is. Yeah, I guess that's reasonable, but Agalloch will totally win this.

 

[The.Donut]

AGALLOCH!

 

[Captain Beard]

I will not vote on the grounds that we lose either way.

 

[JayKeeley]

Quick question: Do I HAVE to pretend everything after Justice exists? I mean, shouldn't this be Metallica 83-88 vs Agalloch?

If this were Metallica 83-88, would everyone still vote Agalloch?

 

[MajestikMøøse]

Agalloch

 

[MajestikMøøse]

Quick question: Do I HAVE to pretend everything after Justice exists? I mean, shouldn't this be Metallica 83-88 vs Agalloch?

Pretend? It isn't metal, but it certainly exists.

 

[Erik]

Quick question: Do I HAVE to pretend everything after Justice exists? I mean, shouldn't this be Metallica 83-88 vs Agalloch?

If this were Metallica 83-88, would everyone still vote Agalloch?

Dude, don't try anything. This is EVERYTHING WITH THE NAME METALLICA ON IT vs EVERYTHING WITH THE NAME AGALLOCH ON IT

 

[NAD]

Everything Agalloch have done is pretty damn good, but they have a short legacy.

Much of what Metallica has done is amazing, some of it is perfectly okay, and a little bit flat out sucks (yes I said just a little bit), but they have a really long legacy.

Metallica.

 

[Ellestin]

I trust Agalloch will leave the battlefield victorious on a high chariot of gold and oak

Metallica

 

[JayKeeley]

What do all these bands have in common:

Black Sabbath
Iron Maiden
Sepultura
Katatonia
Bathory
Burzum
Enslaved

etc.

Huh? I'll tell you:

First half of catalog >>> Last half of catalog

Same shit with Metallica. If we're talking music only (and not the whole MP3 rubbish), I don't see how they're different to 99% of all other bands.

Metallica.

How two Agalloch albums can beat the first 4 Metallica albums is beyond me. But oh well... :Spin:

 

[Krilons Resa]

Agalloch

 

[Captain Beard]

bump so you faggots stop voting in the sticky thread.