Is the reason why all you dislike SOAD because they claim to like the same bands as you, but then write music that sounds different? So Daron likes Black Metal, but that doesn't mean that the influence it has is what SOAD must sound like. If SOAD did a song that sounded just like Darkthrone it'd be crap & dishonest. At least they're being real to themselves, even if it comes across as contradictory at times (the whole anti-corporate thing while signing to Sony etc).
If there's any sort of a drama with SAOD, it's that they may be taking the piss out of their audience in 2005 by saying to think where your money goes, then putting out 2 CDs in the space of a year. The frist CD has 36 minutes of material on it. I scincerely hope the next part, "Hypnotize", will contain more than 44 minutes. Otherwise the buyer's been ripped off (the whole set could therefore fit onto a single CD). It would be indefensible if this happens for SOAD. Daron's already claimed that people would struggle to listen to the set in a single go. I've listened to their 4 albums back-to-back a couple of times now.
People aren't stupid.