I've noticed this same blind reverence toward other categories of classics, particularly classic cars and classic rock.
EDIT: I should clarify that I'm not indiscriminately demeaning classic cars and classic rock. I'm sure there are plenty of reasons for liking either one, but "because it's a classic" isn't an acceptable argument. It's truly irritating when I ask someone why they like something and this is the conversation that follows:
Them: "...because it's a classic, man."
Me: "And what about that appeals to you?"
Them: "Didn't you hear me? It's a classic!"
It's such a clear tautological fallacy that you might as well just admit that you only like it because you've been taught to like it, because you're phishing for the approval of others who like it, or because you're attempting to socially elevate yourself through some symbolic cultural appreciation that others "just wouldn't understand."
this ^^^ is what i was trying to say when i created this thread
quite frequently this type of blindly liking something just simply "because it's classic" can also be applied to things outside of cars and music, i think this type of thinking could specifically be applied to LOTR, Lord of The Flies, and the people that are absolutely convinced that The Hunger Games is somehow a rip-off of something that the author of Hunger Games had never even heard of
if you actually read through LOTR, it's not quite as engaging as the DragonLance books, the Forgotten Realms books, The Wheel of Time Series, the books that got turned into the HBO show "Game of Thrones" etc etc etc
LOTR is only classic because everyone keeps telling everyone else that it's classic
yeah, i get that Tolkien spent his whole fucking life creating Middle-Earth, but was that really a good thing? is it really a good thing to spend your entire life creating a fictional universe? imagine if the publishing house had actually lost money when Tolkien published his first book, imagine what would have happened then, imagine how different, and possibly even better Tolkien life could have been if he'd given up writing and moved on to some other field of work
also, a person who spends their entire fucking life creating a fictional universe can't possibly be considered completely sane, now can he?
also, this is the kind of mentality that spread Christianity into such a huge % of the world
condoms made of animal intestines (to prevent pregnancy in areas where the people had no idea STIs existed) and "coat-hanger type abortions" and pregnant women eating toxic chem to make them have a miscarriage, men fucking women's asses to avoid pregnancy, horny-as-hell dick-sucking women who refused to do penis-in-vagina sex because they didn't want to get pregnant, gay/lesbian people being worshiped because gay/lesbian sex doesn't run the risk of unplanned pregnancy, all these things were all in existence before the birth of Moses, then the cult of monotheism comes, and all of a sudden, homosexuality is wrong, all of a sudden pregnancy-prevention is wrong, all of a sudden abortion/purposeful miscarriage is murder, and all of a sudden sex outside of penis-in-vagina sex is wrong, and all of a sudden the Israelites in Egypt in the time of Moses were having way way more children-per-couple than the Egyptians, then Jesus is born, the Great Commission is written, and all of a sudden Christianity is spread all over the globe because of the same kind of group-think that makes everyone think that LOTR was a well-written book
you've got lots of people that don't question anything the preacher says, where they're Christian just because they're parents are, and adults who start going to Christian Churches just because they live in a city where "everyone else is Christian"