Lina
kickass elizabethan style
Nowhere in my post did I refer to the environment. I was going to point that out earlier when you lumped me in the "environmentalists" category.Can I please ask you something?
Note that what follows is not in the spirit of trying to start a fight or to belittle your opinions - just an attempt at discussion on the matter.
Personally, I do share your worries about the environment, and personally I would not buy a large truck, as I have stated in the past. I also am, in a professional capacity, a supporter of John Roemer's take about letting China and India pollute for a while so that they can get decent living conditions for their people, and try to counterbalance the effect of this necessary evil by using whatever technology we have in order to reduce our own emissions (although I do not believe that we should renounce growth, for a number of reasons that I am willing to debate if you want).
I have nothing to say against overtaxing large cars, as I said before: actually, fairly standard economic theory also points out to the optimality of some disincentives. However, I would stop at tax rates that are blatantly undemocratic, ie they just reflect the desires of 10 per cent of the population, no matter how wise.
But my question is: why do you have to call someone selfish and inconsiderate just because he has different preferences? It's a bit like calling someone bad because they are gay. The attitude is the same: deviate from a given concept of the common good, you're evil. I cannot condone that, except in extreme cases (I think we all agree that pedophilia is an unacceptable threat to the common good, but it is very hard to see whether we do have this right when it comes to our conceptions of the environment, or of the ideal model of family).
My complaints about SUVs/pickups/minivans are based primarily on how they impact other drivers.
I mentioned that taller, wider cars block the view of the trailing car, which is dangerous.
I mentioned that they raise insurance rates for everyone, because when they strike a smaller car the impact causes more damage (not to mention more deaths and injuries).
I mentioned that they spill out of their parking spaces, which is just fucking annoying and rude.
And finally, I mentioned that they're using up a lot of fuel. I threw that in primarily to point out the hypocrisy characteristic of most SUV/pickup drivers in this country, who are inclined to broadcast their supposed patriotism more than other drivers through bumperstickers, even though their choice of vehicle is part of the reason why the U.S. is digging a hole for itself in the world, both militarily and economically.
The first three are clearly selfish and inconsiderate. The last one is far worse.