Having just seen this movie. I would best describe it, as a good representation of the so called "truth" about Jesus Christ's last hours on earth. I think it reflects the true circomstances and atmosphere that reigned during these times, no doubt about that given the fact that Mel Gibson carefully interpreted the writings in the bible to the movie.
I don't think that a subjective opinion about the movie would be valable. Some would just say it was exagerated, just another movie about Christ but in a more bloody and touching scenes. But I don't think it should be commented in such a way, I think each person that watches the movie will perceive it his own way given his own convictions and thoughts.
Now about the anti-semitism in the movie, there is no such thing. No sane Christian would say there is any reference to the guilt of the Jews in our days. Moreover Christ did forgive all the people who condemned him. And he always thaught christians to love their enemies and blabla..
Good movie overall. I liked it.